A Conspiracy of Silence

My aunt was funny, brash, and loving. Athletic and adventurous in her younger days, tender and caring until the day she died, she was adored by everyone.

But she had a secret, sort of….

She was a lesbian.

Everyone knew but they never spoke of it. Perhaps it was best that way since everyone thought it was shameful and wicked. Silence saved us all from discomfort and embarrassment. It was easier.

Okay, maybe not easier, but silence at least made life safer because if she had been open about herself, she could have been in physical danger at times. More recently, I’ve wondered about the emotional and psychological pain she suffered as a consequence of her (and our) silence.

I was still a minister when I had my last face-to-face conversation with Mom before she died. It was early in the morning and we sat at the kitchen table while I told her that Christianity had been wrong to condemn the LGBTQ and I had been wrong in standing by silently. It was my intention, I told her, to begin a support group within my church where the LGBTQ in our community could come to talk and worship. However, while most of my congregation was on board, I still had to find a way to provide privacy for them because Oklahoma, like a lot of regions, is still not friendly to the LGBTQ*

Mom showed a great deal of interest, which surprised me. I thought she’d be uncomfortable, maybe even a little afraid for me. However, she asked me more about my thoughts regarding the scriptures and church doctrine. I told her that Jesus never made an issue of people’s sexuality, and he defended those who had been shamed by society. He said that people would be welcomed into heaven based on acts of love, not their religion.

She nodded and then she told me about her recently deceased sister.

Years before when they were much younger, they had attended a weeklong religious revival. On the last evening, the preacher gave the invitation and while the song played “Just As I Am,” he waited for people to come down the aisle to repent publically of their sins so they could gain forgiveness and redemption.

My aunt looked at Mom who nodded to her in encouragement. And then Mom’s sister went to the front of the church where she was baptized.

For a few moments, my aunt felt forgiven and clean. Her sins were washed away and she was now acceptable in the eyes of God. But redemption doesn’t last long in the church. My aunt remained a lesbian and she went on to have a relationship with her partner that lasted the rest of her life.

My aunt was one of the kindest people the world has known. She checked on the people around her, asking after their health and other concerns. People loved her and opened up to tell her all their problems. And she was generous, giving her time and energy to make people more comfortable. Mom said that she once watched her sister literally give away her last nickel.

“You tell me,” Mom blurted out to me that day in the kitchen, “that a woman like my sister didn’t make it to heaven!”

I assured her that she did.

I don’t believe in heaven or hell or God and Jesus anymore. They’re not real. However, the church and its conspiracy of silent condemnation are quite real.

I find myself shocked at what we did to my aunt and others like her. I’m horrified that we locked my sweet, loveable, funny aunt into a prison of silence, where she dreaded the day she would die and go to the hell we had created. And I think of my mom, who worried that she would never see her sister in heaven. And I think of the people in the LGBTQ who are offered only condemnation by their churches.

I deeply regret that I was a leader in that culture and that I stood by while the silent ones were alone in shame and fear.

I’m so sorry.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

*I moved away from town soon after and never started that support group.

Prayer? Try Rubbing a Lamp

Focus on the Family said in a meme:

 

I don’t wish.

I pray.

Because God is not a genie.

 

There was a time when I would have said the same thing with pride and conviction, holding myself up as an example of holy living.  I might have thrown in a few words to show off my humility but I came off as a bit pompous, nonetheless. 

No Matter How Much You Say a thing, It Doesn’t Make It True.

It always seemed to me that, no matter how much they deny it, most people really do speak to their God as a genie. Perhaps they don’t have to rub a lamp, but they have to keep their hearts clean and shiny, and say the correct words before they can get what they want.  Then, if they don’t get what they want, they are doing something wrong. Or some swear that God actually has answered their prayers, even if there is no evidence. 

I always wanted more than the genie experience.  I preached that praying should be a constant communion of spirits.  I tried to practice it, too.  I poured my heart out for hours at a time, hoping for that presence that “walks with me and talks with me, and tells me I am his own.”

However, that image of God turned out to be as unreal as a genie in the lamp. 

Praying Makes Us Helpless

To me, prayer is admission of helplessness. It indicates that I’m all out of ideas and I need someone to work some magic for me. 

Religious folk will acknowledge this helplessness and then insist that it’s a good thing, perhaps referencing sheep as metaphor.  If we are truly good, they say, we’ll recognize that we are always in a state of helplessness. We cultivate this helplessness in order for God to take a greater role in our lives. 

“We must become less that He might become more.” the preacher says with quiet intensity.

In other words, it gives the genie a chance to work. 

I confess that when I’m exhausted, desperate, and out of ideas, I find myself going back to the praying. 

“If you’re there, after all,” I say, “this would be a great time to appear and help out.”

But he doesn’t. And that’s my cue to go rest and regroup.    

I’ve written my own meme to remind me that I live differently now:

 

I don’t pray.

I think.

And I act.

 

Not Experiencing God

In the last blog entry I asked readers, “Can you describe God without quoting the Bible or using imagery?” I was trying to show that it can’t be done because God can’t be proven.

Several people communicated their thoughtful replies. I want to be respectful but I’m going to argue back.  

Some said that there had to be someone who created everything that exists. “Just look around you, David. Does it make sense that all this just HAPPENED?”  

I’m told that physics actually does explain how everything “just” happened.  However, I’m not a scientist and neither are the people who posed this argument and it didn’t seem productive to continue this discussion.

Except I want to make this observation:

This argument reduces God to a vague entity, a hint that something out there might be behind the appearance of the universe. This is very different from the God of Christianity, which describes a heavenly father who loves people passionately, responds to prayer, communes with our spirits, and remains in charge of everything that is. 

Christianity has formed massive bureaucratic institutions, produced endless volumes of doctrine, and has influenced governments. And the argument for this God’s existence is that there might be something out there that created everything?  

That’s very weak. 

Another argument is that God is immeasurable and the fact that God cannot be proven indicates that God actually exists.  So, not seeing any evidence of God actually reveals his existence…?    

That’s very weak, too. 

Some admitted that their understanding of God was based only on personal experience: their inner feelings and thoughts. They saw God through their interpretation of events in their lives.

I am reluctant to refute someone’s subjective experiences. But I’ll offer my experiences in comparison:    

By faith I believed God to be true. I committed a life of service to this God. I did my best to help the people who followed him. I spent years in school honing my theology as well as my skills as a pastor. I prayed, meditated, worshiped, and studied. My experience is that no one answered me except my own thoughts. 

At some point when my energy failed and I felt utterly alone, I gave up believing. And I’ll tell you something else. If this God really does exist, I don’t care. I won’t continue to pursue a relationship with someone who has ignored me my entire life.

I know there are other people who are haunted by similar thoughts but are reluctant to tell anyone. So I’m saying it for them and I’m here if they want to talk. 

What Is God’s Plan For Me?

What is God’s plan for me?

I’ve asked this question all my life and have never gotten an answer.   Has anybody? 

Not a Bible quote. Not a cryptic message. Not a “sign.” Not a “prompting of the spirit.” Not your own private thought. Not a friend’s strongly expressed opinion. But a clear, unequivocal directive from the Almighty.  

Some claim that they have, but usually they’re pretty subjective.  And on the rare occasion when someone tells me that God actually spoke directly to them, I see haunted eyes glazed over with denial, and I have a hard time believing them.

Most people who are trying to honor God with their actions commit to a lot of study and prayer, then take their best guess as to what God has in mind. And if it doesn’t work out, well then it must have been their fault. They didn’t pray hard enough, or have enough faith, or their hearts weren’t right, or they overlooked the fine print.  Then they would repent, try even harder and be even more careful. 

If we repeat that process enough times we become unable to function.   

Even before I stopped believing altogether, I acknowledged that God never answered my questions so I decided to start taking responsibility for my own actions.  I wouldn’t wait forever for instruction, and I wouldn’t stop at each step, look up for affirmation, and hope I was getting it right.

“We don’t know what God has in mind for you,” I would advise my parishioners. “The only thing you can know for sure is what YOU will do next. So get clear on that.”

Few people liked that answer but it was the only one I had.  It helped me to move forward and stop second guessing myself. 

Whether they believe in God or not, I encourage everyone to take full responsibility for their own actions. Make your decisions, correct your mistakes, and keep moving forward.

Silent Reckoning

I finally admitted to myself that while I prayed constantly, God never answered back. No words came to me. The feelings I experienced were my own.  And the events that happened after I prayed had only the meaning I attributed to them. 

It was painful.  I had poured out my life in service to someone who did not find me worthy of a response.

Friends tried to encourage me, saying that perhaps God is so great that I simply could not understand his communication. I accepted this thought for most of my life.  But I came to the conclusion that if God was all powerful, surely he could find a way to get through to me. (BTW, the story of God sending his Son is not direct communication, either). 

In one of my final one sided conversations with this unseen, unheard entity, I said “I will continue to care for people and do the things I assume are important to you because they’re important to me, too. If you decide someday to talk to me about that, I’m right here.”  As usual, I got no response but I quit expecting one and I went about my work. 

I still prayed publicly for the sake of my people.  I reflected their thoughts and hopes.  And I relied on the liturgies written by others. But my personal outpouring stopped.

God has remained silent, too.    

Photo by Sylvia Kirkendoll Mercer