Drowning in the Baptismal Waters

She was eleven years old.

She had been at an evangelical church camp–a week full of morning Bible studies and evening assemblies with emotionally charged music, stories, and sermons. On the final night, the guest preacher spoke of their need to be forgiven of their sins to be saved from eternal hell and to beg for the gift of heaven.   

The girl walked up the aisle and said she wanted to be baptized.  The people applauded and shouted “Amen!” Her tears flowed freely and the preacher explained it was because the Holy Spirit had gotten hold of her.   

I was one of the spiritual guides at that camp and I was assigned to “counsel” her on the spot. While she sat in the pew, sobbing, I knelt in front of her so I could see her face. 

“Have you been baptized before?” I asked. 

“Yes, but I need to do it again,” she said.

“You don’t really have to,” I said. “You’re already saved.”  

“Yes, I do,” she insisted. “Because I’ve been so bad since then!” 

“Why don’t you wait till you go home and you can talk about it with your parents?” I suggested. 

“No! I have to do it now!”

I was afraid she was about to reach a new level of hysteria.  I said, “Okay, but first let’s call your parents on the phone. They’ll want to know.”

She nodded.

As I led her from the crowd, she said in a broken voice: “I’m so happy…”

After talking to her parents, she decided to wait until she got home where she could be baptized in her own church. I was relieved that we slowed things down so she could rest and be with her family first.   

“I’ve been so bad,” she said. 

At eleven years of age, what could she have done that was so bad? Did she sass her parents? Had she snuck out at night to be with her friends? Had she gone “all the way”?

Did these things make her evil? Did she deserve to burn in hell forever? That’s what we taught her.  In fact, there were many lesser things, including “bad thoughts,” that would send her to hell.  Her only escape was to have special words said over her and then dunked (again) underwater.

It was a long time ago and I’ve had darker questions since then.

What if she had been molested?  What if someone had told her it was her fault? It has taken me a long time to see that our religion could be a tool to prey on the vulnerable.  The baptismal waters come closer to drowning them rather than cleansing them.     

I’m ashamed that I was part of a system that says people are evil and deserve to burn eternally.

At the time, I thought of myself as a reformer who was changing the church from the inside in Jesus’ name. I did my best to shield people like this girl from abuse but I was merely helping adjust things enough to allow an unhealthy institution to continue functioning.

I wish I had never been a part of it. Yet I also wish I had helped her more while I was there.

“Honey,” I could have said, “I don’t care what you’ve done, there’s nothing evil about you. You are a wonderful person. You don’t need to be saved. If there is a god, I’m sure he likes you fine.”

In fact, I wish I had stood up and told all the kids the same thing and then said, “You’re all marvelous, just as you are, and you don’t have to listen to this crap.  In fact, we can all stand up, march out of this place, go home, and be happy.

“C’mon. I’ll go first.”   

 

Southern Baptist Terror

It’s appalling.

The Southern Baptist preacher stood before the neighborhood children, some as young as five years old, who had come to Vacation Bible School. After a week of stories, crafts, and cookies, they had come to the big moment where he delivered the coup de grace.

“We’ve been telling you about Jesus,” he said. “Jesus loves you so much that he wants to save you from hell and take you to heaven when you die.”

“Let me ask you,” He said, increasing in intensity, “if you were to die in your sleep tonight, Where would you go…?

“I’ll tell you where… You’d go to hell to be with the devil. Do you want to live forever in a place seven times hotter than the sun?”

None of them did.

“Who here would rather be saved from their sins and go to heaven to live forever with Jesus?”

All of them did.

“Then with every eye closed and every head bowed. Say this in your heart with me.

praying hands
Child Prayer Hands. Photo | Stock Image | ishareimage.com

“Dear God, I am a sinner. I’m sorry for all the bad things I’ve done. Dear Jesus, please come into my heart. Forgive my sins. Deliver me from the devil and take me to heaven.”

Then the preacher addressed the children. “Now, with your heads still bowed and eyes still closed, if you said this prayer with me and you are ready to give your heart to Christ tonight, raise your hand.

Since everyone’s eyes were closed, we’ll just have to guess who raised their hands.

When they opened their eyes, the pastor told them that they needed to be baptized as soon as possible. Even if they had been baptized in another church, it was not good enough… they had to be baptized at the Baptist church.

I know of one five year old child who went home deeply afraid that he would die in his sleep and go to hell. When his family found out why he was so scared they called me. I visited with the boy and it took a lot to reassure him that he was in no danger.

I’m sorry to say that this happens all the time. In fact, I could tell of worse things. I’ve had to sooth a lot of children who were scared to death by other pastors.
Today is Ash Wednesday and in other denominations some Christians will have observed a rite emphasizing their sinfulness and mortality. It’s okay by me, I guess, because it’s their choice.

But children don’t have a choice and they should not be forced to carry such a burden in their hearts. We are supposed to keep them safe from terror.

I’m not a Sinner. I’m a Person

I’m not a sinner. I’m a person. 

I posted this on Facebook and received some powerful reactions.  My minister pals responded with gentleness and support.  Other friends, though they were kind, equated my statement with total rejection of the Christian doctrine and it confused them to hear this coming from a pastor.   Some cheered me on even as they poured out their stories of having been rejected by their Christian communities.

Is it really so shocking that I insist I am a whole person complete with conflicting attributes? And excuse me if I sound guilty of the sin of pride, but  I’m pretty damned interesting.  I can be brilliant, dumb, generous and petty.  I sing, whisper, yell, and mumble.   I laugh loud, wail inconsolably, burn with rage, and love with passion. I work hard and occasionally I struggle through the minutia to accomplish big things. I’ve also helped people throughout my life. 

All these things count.  I won’t exclude them all and focus only on the bad stuff.

But let’s think this through.  Am I a sinner? I’ve searched myself all my life like a good little Christian to ferret out all my inner evil and I’ve enjoyed about as much of that misery as I can stand.  But if I must, I’ll give myself one final quickie—oops, using that word is probably a sin.  But let’s move on.    

Have I hurt others? Yeah, so okay, those are sins.  Additionally, others have said I have hurt them and they expect me to hang my head and feel bad. I can’t argue because that would probably be a sin, too. On the other hand, I’ve avoided the biggies—murder, robbery, tearing labels off mattresses.  But it’s a sin to brag about the bad things I’ve avoided.  Also, I’ve done some pretty good things, but thinking about how good I am is a sin, too.

Then there are the sins of omission—the endless list of things I am not doing but should be.  Also, my inner thoughts of the bad things I wish I could be doing—they’re sins too.  And then the feelings—jealousy, fear, anger, sexual desire, grief—I shouldn’t have them so those are also sins. 

Finally, we say that sin is anything less than perfection.  So as I sit here with imperfect posture, my fingers using the backspace key while I type in my flawed thoughts, I’m supposed to agree that there’s never a moment when I’m not sinning. 

Fine. You win. If we exclude every other fact about me, we can call me a miserable, scum sucking, sinner.  And so are you.  And so is everyone. 

It’s probably a sin to say this is crazy.  But it is. 

Quote a Bible verse or two, or a hundred, but it’s doesn’t make it less crazy. Weave your thoughts into a weird doctrinal narrative and call it “God’s love,” and that makes it more crazy.  Shout it from ten thousand protestant pulpits and the craziness grows. Teach it lovingly to the children in classrooms and we’ve elevated it to wickedness.   

So I want to say sincerely, I’m sorry but I’m not a sinner.  I’m sorry I ever believed that I was.  I’m sorry I told others they were sinners.  I’m sorry I preached it in the pulpit and taught it in the classroom and shared it to families in their living rooms. 

I repent. I take it back. 

Condemn me for it if you must, but I’m not a sinner. And neither are you.  We are persons.