A Conspiracy of Silence

My aunt was funny, brash, and loving. Athletic and adventurous in her younger days, tender and caring until the day she died, she was adored by everyone.

But she had a secret, sort of….

She was a lesbian.

Everyone knew but they never spoke of it. Perhaps it was best that way since everyone thought it was shameful and wicked. Silence saved us all from discomfort and embarrassment. It was easier.

Okay, maybe not easier, but silence at least made life safer because if she had been open about herself, she could have been in physical danger at times. More recently, I’ve wondered about the emotional and psychological pain she suffered as a consequence of her (and our) silence.

I was still a minister when I had my last face-to-face conversation with Mom before she died. It was early in the morning and we sat at the kitchen table while I told her that Christianity had been wrong to condemn the LGBTQ and I had been wrong in standing by silently. It was my intention, I told her, to begin a support group within my church where the LGBTQ in our community could come to talk and worship. However, while most of my congregation was on board, I still had to find a way to provide privacy for them because Oklahoma, like a lot of regions, is still not friendly to the LGBTQ*

Mom showed a great deal of interest, which surprised me. I thought she’d be uncomfortable, maybe even a little afraid for me. However, she asked me more about my thoughts regarding the scriptures and church doctrine. I told her that Jesus never made an issue of people’s sexuality, and he defended those who had been shamed by society. He said that people would be welcomed into heaven based on acts of love, not their religion.

She nodded and then she told me about her recently deceased sister.

Years before when they were much younger, they had attended a weeklong religious revival. On the last evening, the preacher gave the invitation and while the song played “Just As I Am,” he waited for people to come down the aisle to repent publically of their sins so they could gain forgiveness and redemption.

My aunt looked at Mom who nodded to her in encouragement. And then Mom’s sister went to the front of the church where she was baptized.

For a few moments, my aunt felt forgiven and clean. Her sins were washed away and she was now acceptable in the eyes of God. But redemption doesn’t last long in the church. My aunt remained a lesbian and she went on to have a relationship with her partner that lasted the rest of her life.

My aunt was one of the kindest people the world has known. She checked on the people around her, asking after their health and other concerns. People loved her and opened up to tell her all their problems. And she was generous, giving her time and energy to make people more comfortable. Mom said that she once watched her sister literally give away her last nickel.

“You tell me,” Mom blurted out to me that day in the kitchen, “that a woman like my sister didn’t make it to heaven!”

I assured her that she did.

I don’t believe in heaven or hell or God and Jesus anymore. They’re not real. However, the church and its conspiracy of silent condemnation are quite real.

I find myself shocked at what we did to my aunt and others like her. I’m horrified that we locked my sweet, loveable, funny aunt into a prison of silence, where she dreaded the day she would die and go to the hell we had created. And I think of my mom, who worried that she would never see her sister in heaven. And I think of the people in the LGBTQ who are offered only condemnation by their churches.

I deeply regret that I was a leader in that culture and that I stood by while the silent ones were alone in shame and fear.

I’m so sorry.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

*I moved away from town soon after and never started that support group.

Drowning in the Baptismal Waters

She was eleven years old.

She had been at an evangelical church camp–a week full of morning Bible studies and evening assemblies with emotionally charged music, stories, and sermons. On the final night, the guest preacher spoke of their need to be forgiven of their sins to be saved from eternal hell and to beg for the gift of heaven.   

The girl walked up the aisle and said she wanted to be baptized.  The people applauded and shouted “Amen!” Her tears flowed freely and the preacher explained it was because the Holy Spirit had gotten hold of her.   

I was one of the spiritual guides at that camp and I was assigned to “counsel” her on the spot. While she sat in the pew, sobbing, I knelt in front of her so I could see her face. 

“Have you been baptized before?” I asked. 

“Yes, but I need to do it again,” she said.

“You don’t really have to,” I said. “You’re already saved.”  

“Yes, I do,” she insisted. “Because I’ve been so bad since then!” 

“Why don’t you wait till you go home and you can talk about it with your parents?” I suggested. 

“No! I have to do it now!”

I was afraid she was about to reach a new level of hysteria.  I said, “Okay, but first let’s call your parents on the phone. They’ll want to know.”

She nodded.

As I led her from the crowd, she said in a broken voice: “I’m so happy…”

After talking to her parents, she decided to wait until she got home where she could be baptized in her own church. I was relieved that we slowed things down so she could rest and be with her family first.   

“I’ve been so bad,” she said. 

At eleven years of age, what could she have done that was so bad? Did she sass her parents? Had she snuck out at night to be with her friends? Had she gone “all the way”?

Did these things make her evil? Did she deserve to burn in hell forever? That’s what we taught her.  In fact, there were many lesser things, including “bad thoughts,” that would send her to hell.  Her only escape was to have special words said over her and then dunked (again) underwater.

It was a long time ago and I’ve had darker questions since then.

What if she had been molested?  What if someone had told her it was her fault? It has taken me a long time to see that our religion could be a tool to prey on the vulnerable.  The baptismal waters come closer to drowning them rather than cleansing them.     

I’m ashamed that I was part of a system that says people are evil and deserve to burn eternally.

At the time, I thought of myself as a reformer who was changing the church from the inside in Jesus’ name. I did my best to shield people like this girl from abuse but I was merely helping adjust things enough to allow an unhealthy institution to continue functioning.

I wish I had never been a part of it. Yet I also wish I had helped her more while I was there.

“Honey,” I could have said, “I don’t care what you’ve done, there’s nothing evil about you. You are a wonderful person. You don’t need to be saved. If there is a god, I’m sure he likes you fine.”

In fact, I wish I had stood up and told all the kids the same thing and then said, “You’re all marvelous, just as you are, and you don’t have to listen to this crap.  In fact, we can all stand up, march out of this place, go home, and be happy.

“C’mon. I’ll go first.”   

 

Too Busy Living to be Held Back by Religion

Emma was confined to her wheelchair, but her eyes twinkled as she regaled me with many stories about herself.  Despite having suffered from polio at an early age, she grew up to have many adventures: swimming the deepest lakes, diving from the highest cliffs, riding fast cars, and dancing late into the night.  And she had romantic relationships with many men though she never married.

She was now in her eighties and while she seemed full of life, her time was short and a fear was bubbling to the surface.  So she decided to confide to the young minister who had come to visit her. 

“David, I’m afraid I’m going to hell.”

I was only twenty-three but it wasn’t the first time someone told me that and it wouldn’t be the last time.

“Why do you think so, Emma?” I asked.

“Because of all the men I was with,” she said.

I nodded.

“Why did God make me such a passionate woman,” she wailed, “if he didn’t want me to act this way?” 

It seemed like a fair question to me.

At the beginning of my ministry, even when I was ultra conservative, I differed with church doctrine. While others might have given Emma a verbose lecture about the virtue of morality, I opted to reassure her. I said God loved her and whatever sins she thought she had committed were already forgiven, and I was sure she was safe from eternal damnation.

If I was wrong, then God could come down, shut my mouth, and explain how could he be anything but delighted with this woman. But since he remained silent, I went with my own thoughts.

I encountered many people like Emma over the years.  They traveled, partied, had interesting hobbies, cherished their loved ones, fought their battles, and made their peace. They may have been religious but they rarely had time for church.  Often, they felt the same anxiety that Emma did, but like her they couldn’t let it tie them down.

Concepts like faith, spirituality, and religion ought to expand our lives, helping us to see further, live fully, and feel more deeply. Yet religion often restrains us, makes us second guess ourselves, and leads us to frown on those who have too much fun. 

Emma lived a rich life that could not be restrained by polio or religion.  When she died a few weeks later, people came to cry and laugh as they told stories about her.  And no one wondered about her eternal destiny. 

The Weakness of the Cross

Behind the talk of God’s love lurks the shame and anxiety that has always been the driving force of church.  Tonight’s Good Friday service will once again hammer home the gory details of the crucifixion. People will weep and nod in solemn agreement that it was their own sinfulness that caused Jesus’ agony.

We use the story to tap into the shame and anxiety that most of us harbor inside ourselves all the time. And we’ll use it to motivate ourselves to do good deeds.

But there’s a problem and it’s a big one. 

Shame and fear do not promote nobility. They make us sick with an anguish that fosters addiction, and corruption. They further lead us to conceal these miseries so that we can’t face ourselves and make our corrections. 

Church is the place where people are scared to really face themselves. On Sundays, with few exceptions, they won’t talk about the things that keep them up late at night with fear and shame.  Instead, they put on their nice clothes, plaster smiles on their faces, and talk about how blessed they are.  And perhaps they whisper to each other the terrible secrets their neighbors are harboring.

People will read this and feel defensive. Or perhaps they’ll feel shame because they’ll recognize the truth of what I’m saying and blame themselves for it.  But it’s not their fault.

The problem is systemic with no specific person to blame.  Church can’t be a place for openness and healing when its basic premise is that people are awful sinners who caused the death of God’s child. 

We need a safe place where there is no pressure, where people are loved with softness, and humanity is celebrated with quiet joy. Wouldn’t it be amazing if there were a place where people could freely air their true worries and flaws, where they could help each other with authentic words of comfort and encouragement?

Too bad we can’t find that at church.