One of My Biggest Regrets

They’d never seen me mad before and it startled everyone in that church board meeting.  I’d raised my voice and threatened to quit, which I thought was quite restrained of me considering that I wanted to rip the tables and chairs out of my path to put my hands on the guy who had just spoken critically of my wife.

I later apologized for my anger but every week when I saw that guy in church, I had to resist the urge to grab him by the lapels, pin him to the wall, and express my feelings.

It was several years ago and my former wife and I have gone our separate ways. However, I still feel a bitter rage wash over me when I think of that moment.  To be fair, my anger is not from that one instance and it’s not just at that one person (although I hope never to see him again).

One of the biggest regrets I have is how much I expected my family to contribute to my professional ministry.  I made my kids come to the church activities and I pressed my spouse into service.  Whenever I went to interview for a new job, my family had to be interviewed too.

I was raised in a minister’s home and so I never thought it inappropriate for a church to have expectations of the preacher’s family.  But it was pointed out to me recently that no other organization can expect an employee’s family to participate in his or her profession.

A few of my churches treated my wife and children decently but most of the years were grim for the family, where they were used up with little recognition. I’m angry at myself for allowing it.  If I had it to do over, I would tell my family that I did not expect them to participate in any church activities—worship, classes, potlucks, VBS, etc—unless they wanted to.  And I would tell my church leadership not to expect anything of them.

To all my minister friends, I encourage you to do what I failed to do and protect your families. Release them from obligation to participate in your profession with you.

 

See David Mercer’s new website:  damercerlife.com

 

The Weakness of the Cross

Behind the talk of God’s love lurks the shame and anxiety that has always been the driving force of church.  Tonight’s Good Friday service will once again hammer home the gory details of the crucifixion. People will weep and nod in solemn agreement that it was their own sinfulness that caused Jesus’ agony.

We use the story to tap into the shame and anxiety that most of us harbor inside ourselves all the time. And we’ll use it to motivate ourselves to do good deeds.

But there’s a problem and it’s a big one. 

Shame and fear do not promote nobility. They make us sick with an anguish that fosters addiction, and corruption. They further lead us to conceal these miseries so that we can’t face ourselves and make our corrections. 

Church is the place where people are scared to really face themselves. On Sundays, with few exceptions, they won’t talk about the things that keep them up late at night with fear and shame.  Instead, they put on their nice clothes, plaster smiles on their faces, and talk about how blessed they are.  And perhaps they whisper to each other the terrible secrets their neighbors are harboring.

People will read this and feel defensive. Or perhaps they’ll feel shame because they’ll recognize the truth of what I’m saying and blame themselves for it.  But it’s not their fault.

The problem is systemic with no specific person to blame.  Church can’t be a place for openness and healing when its basic premise is that people are awful sinners who caused the death of God’s child. 

We need a safe place where there is no pressure, where people are loved with softness, and humanity is celebrated with quiet joy. Wouldn’t it be amazing if there were a place where people could freely air their true worries and flaws, where they could help each other with authentic words of comfort and encouragement?

Too bad we can’t find that at church. 

An Awful Power

She was lonely and grieving. She came to the revival because she needed… something. 

The speaker noticed the attractive blonde sitting by herself in the crowd, eyes wide and glistening, and her head bobbing at everything he said.  He caught her eye again and again during the sermon, staring just a beat longer than necessary. 

When he gave his invitation he said, “The Holy Spirit has a special word for someone tonight.” (She nodded).  “This person has been waiting a long time to hear from God.” (nod, nod). “This person has been separated from God because of SIN, but tonight is her time to RELEASE all that holds her back.” (nod, stifled sob).

Then he stepped off the podium and slowly walked up the aisle, pointing his finger at my friend.

“Sister!” he continued with building volume, “Won’t you allow the Spirit of the Lord to enter in and make his dwelling in your heart?”

Tears streamed down her face as she cried, “Yes, Yes, Oh yes!”

Then he did that thing that Pentecostal ministers do where he placed his hand on her forehead and she collapsed.  Two big deacons had placed themselves behind her and caught her as she fell.   The preacher moved onto his next victim.

Nothing mystical or spiritual happened here. The preacher’s practiced eye had seen a vulnerable person and to make the show more dramatic he took advantage.

It’s a form of rape.

In addition to vulnerable ones like her, shills placed throughout the audience are cued to fall at the preacher’s touch. Then the power of suggestion takes over and plenty of people will keel over, too. They have no idea they are being manipulated.  

It happens every Sunday in churches all over the world. 

I’m frustrated that people allow themselves to be so easily controlled. And it makes me angry that someone would use the pulpit to manipulate and brutalize others.   

When I was a pastor I never practiced that “faith healing” crap. I was always aware of the power people gave me and I tried not to harm them.  I didn’t scream, accuse, or manipulate people. I didn’t claim any special word from on high. And I didn’t let the music go on and on, holding the church hostage until someone came forward to be “saved.”

Yet even with my muted style, I could see people looking at me, waiting for a holy message to make them feel less desperate. It disturbed me to be given so much power.

Want to know a secret? I used to feel inadequate and embarrassed that I got so few responses from my sermons. But now I’m glad I was a failure.

I was never comfortable taking on the “Man of God” role, showing a confidence I didn’t feel, demonstrating a faith that was never so firm as my voice.  I hoped one day to grow into it the role but instead I grew out of it. It only took me thirty-five years.

I have many minister friends who are humble and want only to help.  But the culture in which we function compels us to wield way too much power where people will accept anything we say without critical examination. It’s one of the dynamics that allows many religious leaders to get caught up in scandal.  

I still want to help those who are lonely and grieving but now I do it as one person to another, with no magic tricks, no gimmicks, and no power trips.   

You Don’t Have to Forgive

In my last years of ministry, I quit preaching about forgiveness because it did more harm than good. 

When I did speak on the subject, I was aiming at the grudge-holding, petty sniping that went on where people used their resentment to keep others trapped in shame.  However those people never heard me except to use my words to inflict more wounds on their victims.   

Enough of that. 

With whatever remnants of pastoral authority I still have, I want to say this to the victims of violence and sexual assault:

You don’t have to forgive your abuser. 

I know, I know… the Bible says don’t let the sun go down on your anger.  But frankly, I think it would be better to go to bed mad rather than scared or hopeless.  Get out of harm’s way if you can. You’ve turned the cheek plenty of times.  It’s time to rescue yourself. By the way, asking for help is part of the rescue operation.   

I hope that there will be a day when the sun goes down and you can finally go to bed feeling… safe.

My friend, Dr. Christy Sim, is an expert on surviving and healing.  You can see her website at https://drchristysim.wordpress.com/.  If you’d like to support her work, go to https://www.patreon.com/DrChristySim