A Challenge to My Christian Friends

Tell about your theology using critical reasoning.  How do you know that what you believe is true? 

Everybody in seminary has to do this. It’s an exercise to separate fact from feeling and truth from bias.  Many are quite shaken by the assignment.

Which reminds me… before you read further, let me say two things. First, if you’re in a vulnerable state, such as grief or illness, just skip over this post. Second, if you read further and it’s too disturbing, please understand that you can walk away from your computer screen and go right back to the security of your faith. I’ll understand.

I’m asking you to show me that your God is real.  Don’t tell me to go read a book or watch a movie or listen to your special preacher.  1 Peter 3:15 says to always be ready to give an account of your hope to someone who asks. So here I am, asking. 

Ready? Let’s begin.   

Can you describe God without using imagery? 

A clever story isn’t going to get the job done.  I’ve heard a lot of them and at one time I told them from the pulpit.  Metaphors, analogies, illustrations, and other literary devices can be valuable in their descriptive powers but they don’t prove anything. 

I’m aware that this takes out your best stuff: All those great preacher stories. And the biblical images: God is love. God is light. He is Abba Father. God is a nursing mother,  the Lord is our Shepherd.  Don’t forget the more severe ones where God is a Judge or a defending warrior.  And then there’s all that stuff in Revelation.

It’s all quite dramatic but it’s not proof.  If your God is real, you shouldn’t have to rely on imagery to talk about him. 

On to the next question:  

Can your God be described without quoting the Bible?

I’m a skeptic, and you can understand that your telling me the Bible is the inspired Word of God because the Bible says so just isn’t going to cut it.  Besides, truth is truth and it can stand on its own without having to quote chapter and verse.  So tell me something true.  

And don’t tell me to just open my eyes, look up, and see…. That’s subjective stuff.  Pointing to a flower, or a rhinoceros, or the sky and telling me that God made it… that’s not proof.  Neither is it proof when events worked out favorably after you prayed–that’s still subjective.  

This is the point where most people get exasperated, throw up their hands and mutter something about casting their pearls before swine.  You’ll want to dismiss me by saying God will remain a mystery as long as I refuse to believe.  But I don’t refuse to believe. I always wanted to believe.  I’ve spent my life trying to believe.  

So don’t be ashamed of your gospel.  You want to stand up for Jesus, don’t you?  You want to win me over don’t you? Wouldn’t that be a feather in your cap?  

However, you should be fair.  I want the chance to persuade you, too, not because I want you to come over to my side and not because I’m trying to deliver you to the devil.  I aim to win you over to yourself where you can own your thoughts and make your choices.   

I want to engage in real conversation.  I’ll try very hard to be respectful. I know that many of us atheists can get cranky and perhaps you can understand where that comes from when you realize that many of them have been ridiculed, excluded, and attacked by the people they love. Some have lost everything—jobs, marriages, family, children…. But I promise I won’t be mean to you, and I’ll ask my atheist friends who comment here to do the same.  

So talk to me in the comment section. Or you can email me, if you like, at damercer1961@gmail.com.  

A Place at the Table

I wrote this several years ago when I was still a preacher and I published it in my anonymous blog, Clergy Guy. Maybe it will help some understand more about real ministers.

I was at a ministers’ meeting feeling grumpy because I didn’t want to be there. I sat at a table with colleagues who didn’t want to be there either.  I didn’t know them all, but I could see they were all ministers.  Trust me, we recognize each other.

However, there was one man at the table whom I was sure was not a minister, although he was dressed like one with his dark suit and tie. He looked a little like most of us, too–big, overweight, with that indefinable quality of oddness we persons of the cloth often possess.  But he wasn’t one of us, no matter how much he looked the part. I can’t tell you how I knew that, but I did.  Trust me, we recognize each other. 

After a few minutes, he leaned over to me and gestured toward the rest of the room where hundreds of other ministers were gathered.

“All these people sit with their classmates from seminary.” he said. “It happens at all these events.  They only talk to people in their class.  You ever noticed that?” 

“Not really,” I said. 

“Oh, it’s true,” he assured me.

No it wasn’t but I didn’t argue.

“I notice things like that,” he said importantly, “I’m a people watcher.”

“Really?” I said.

“Yeah. It’s kind of my hobby.  When my wife makes me go to the mall with her, I’m never bored. I just watch all the people go by. It’s very entertaining .”

I smiled and nodded just as if I was interested.  I didn’t like him. What was this guy doing here?

I looked at a friend sitting across from me.  He was a high mileage minister like me who, also like me, had eschewed the conventional coat and tie for this event. He’s goofy and quite outrageous in a soft spoken manner, but he still has the pastor’s presence–that carriage of caring authority. Other ministers, who were better dressed than him or me, sat on either side of him.  We like to be around him because he makes us laugh. Not the fake life-of-the-party kind of laugh that we use at church socials, but the helpless belly busting laughter that sad ministers don’t get enough of. 

He’s sad, too, because like the rest of us, he struggles to run a church, arbitrate ludicrous conflicts, raise money, and attract new members, while all the time he is aware that his real job is to calm the turmoil in others, comfort the grieving, and sit with the dying. Another reason for his sadness is that like the rest of us, he feels inadequate for the job.

The man who liked to watch people for entertainment did not belong with us at this table. 

You see, unlike him, we don’t watch people. We watch over people. We watch for the ones who need rescue.  We see the wounds and try to heal them. It’s hard work with a high failure rate, and it’s rarely entertaining.  But it’s the real work that we squeeze in around the committee meetings, training seminars, building campaigns, and potluck socials.

Inside, I sneered at this guy who watches people. But now that I’m alone and have time to process, I think about what he really said to me. 

He watches people who don’t see him and perhaps like me they are irritated when he insists on being noticed.  

Yesterday he sat, invisible again, in a room of hundreds of ministers. He was dressed the same as everyone else, but wasn’t really one of us and he thought he had an explanation: 

I’m not in their class. 

Sigh. He was one of those that I’m supposed to be watching for and he was right next to me. 

Like I said. High failure rate. Inadequate for the job.  

Reactions

“I was a minister for a long time,” I say, “but I left because I don’t believe in God anymore.”

Inevitably, this happens in the polite “getting know you” part of the conversation.  If I try to avoid saying it, it just gets it more awkward, so I come right out with it.  

I thought about inventing a different backstory:  I was a pirate…  Or I’m in the Protected Witness Program…  Or I bumped my head and don’t remember anything… by the way, are you my mommy?

I guess not.

People are gracious about it, even if they’re shocked.  No one has challenged me to fisticuffs, pistols, or dueling Bibles. However, they really don’t know what to say and I guess I still don’t either.

I remember one guy I encountered at the library. We’d had just gotten into the introductions when he asked what I did for a living.  He became so quiet when I told him that I could almost hear the gears whirring in his head as he considered his words: Don’t blow it!  This is my big chance to reclaim one of God’s lost lambs. Is there a verse I can quote?

I suggested he relax and tell me about his work (he was a minister). 

Some will invite me to their church, assuring me that theirs is different from all the others, which I doubt is true. In any case, I’m not going to go, but I usually respond with a quiet thank you. 

A lot of people ask me if something happened, perhaps a loss or illness, etc.  I consider the loneliness, depression, and confusion I’ve experienced.   One thing…?  

“Not really,” I answer.  

Some have said, “Maybe God is not through with you yet.”

This is where a flash of anger goes through me and I want to say, “Let me be clear. If your God exists, I’m through with HIM!” But they didn’t intend to be hurtful so I offer a nod and a pleasant smile.  

One guy lit up when I told him I no longer believed. He took it as a challenge to win me over, and so he “witnessed” to me, telling what God had done in his life.  I don’t think he took a breath for two hours.  He nearly wore me out before I could get away. 

Some people feel guilty, like they’re responsible for my “fall.” Again, I have to tamp down the initial angry response.  “I didn’t fall and I’m not lost. You didn’t cause this. I make my own decisions.”  

I usually just say, “It’s okay. It’s not anyone’s fault.”  

Then there are those who become afraid after I tell them. Mostly, their fear is wordless but they say enough to indicate they’re frightened about all they would lose  if I’m right and they’re wrong. I feel bad for them and I try to reassure them. I might reach out to pat them on the shoulder like I would have when I was a minister.  “It’s okay,” I say, “I’m not trying to win you over to my side.” But most of the time I can’t be reassuring enough and they slip away out danger.  

This discussion makes us all tense. I haven’t found a smooth way to get into it, even when I’m simply introducing myself.  I guess the first lesson is for me to get more comfortable with myself.  Then maybe I’ll be able to help others feel more comfortable around me. Even if I can’t, I’ll still feel be more relaxed.

You Told Me To… and I Did

“What happened to you, David?

“When you were young, we were so proud. You grew up in our church. You knew the answers in Sunday school. You sang the hymns. You were baptized at the proper age of twelve. Later, you went to the youth gatherings and said the sweetest prayers. We watched you go off to Bible college and we knew you’d become a fine little preacher.

“What happened to you? Did we do something to cause you to fall away?”

Well… Let me put it to you this way:

You said to pray every day, and I did. But when I whispered to you that it didn’t seem like anyone was listening, you said to try harder, so I did, and it didn’t help.

You said to study the Bible, and I did. But when I became an expert in biblical studies and told you that the Bible said things you never told me about, you were indignant.

You said to tell the truth, and I did. But you didn’t like hearing something other than what you’d always heard and so you urged me to hush before I got into trouble.

You said to love the unlovely, and I did. But I found that you didn’t mean the homeless, and Blacks and Hispanics and those homosexuals.

You ask what happened to me. The answer is I did what you told me to do. In some ways,  I still do.

“Now hold on, you can’t blame us. We never claimed to be perfect but it’s not our fault that you fell from the one true way. You have to take responsibility for your own actions. You have to think for yourself.”

I do. My life is my own. You don’t have to take any blame for how I turned out.

Can’t We Still Be Friends?

Religious belief is not a matter of intellectual choice or emotional attachment.  For most of us it’s a powerful legacy passed on to us and it’s not easy to leave.  However, when we do, we leave behind a community which can include profound friendships, parents, siblings, grandparents, cousins, spouses, and even children.

I did not experience the angry exchanges as other newly outed atheists have.  People were gracious to me. I wasn’t fired from my job. I voluntarily left my career.  But many people I have known and loved the longest have faded away.

It’s understandable enough. Our paths take different directions that can separate us.  I don’t work alongside them, anymore.  I relocated so I don’t run into them at the supermarket.  But there’s no denying that many have chosen not to engage with me anymore.

A few stayed with me. They know who they are and I appreciate them.  I also think many people keep a quiet watch over me but they can’t appear too friendly without risking their other relationships. I get that, and I sympathize. 

Of course, breaks in relationships are often messier than I just described.  I look back and see real mistakes I made that contributed to some of my losses.  However, it’s clear to me that I’ve lost people because I no longer share their religion.

I was hoping I could have my own thoughts, express my views, and even debate them strenuously, yet stay friends. Is that possible? I still love these people and would never reject them. In fact, I’m still here for them.

 

Church Camp

I tried to love church camp like my colleagues claimed to, but I couldn’t. Being away from my family for a week or two, exposed to nature’s bugs, skunks, and snakes, plus sleeping in an unairconditioned cabin with a bunch of preadolescent boys was never my idea of a good time.

Call me a poor sport. Call me a sissy. Just don’t call me to be a camp counselor ever again.

But more importantly than my discomfort, I have some real concerns for the kids that attend.

First, let me say I’ve hesitated to speak about this because I have dear friends who have invested themselves in giving kids good experiences in camp. They have no intention of engineering a manipulative atmosphere as revealed in the documentary, Jesus Camp.  I’ll even agree that many camp leaders, especially in United Methodist camps, are diligent in showing respect for the campers.  Furthermore, many people tell me they have great memories of attending church camp.

I believe them but I’m still concerned. I say that even with the best intentions, there’s a great deal of manipulation happening in church camps.

Tell me I’m wrong… that these elements are not in church camps:

Isolation where young ones are away from home and family.

Sleep deprivation where they wake up early and stay up late.

Exhaustion from physical activities including long hikes.

Indoctrination from the small group sharing sessions, exciting music, emotional storytelling, using scripture like incantations, and pressuring the children to give their hearts to Jesus.

Of course the kids respond to the invitation… sobbing as they stumble up the aisles, offering themselves to God, mistaking their fatigue for spirituality.

I actually helped at these camps, thinking it was good for the kids. But I’ve changed my mind and I’m sorry I was ever a part of them. Again, I don’t think those who led these camps meant to hurt anyone. They were trying to help, to give kids a good experience.

But I still think it’s wrong.

One of My Biggest Regrets

They’d never seen me mad before and it startled everyone in that church board meeting.  I’d raised my voice and threatened to quit, which I thought was quite restrained of me considering that I wanted to rip the tables and chairs out of my path to put my hands on the guy who had just spoken critically of my wife.

I later apologized for my anger but every week when I saw that guy in church, I had to resist the urge to grab him by the lapels, pin him to the wall, and express my feelings.

It was several years ago and my former wife and I have gone our separate ways. However, I still feel a bitter rage wash over me when I think of that moment.  To be fair, my anger is not from that one instance and it’s not just at that one person (although I hope never to see him again).

One of the biggest regrets I have is how much I expected my family to contribute to my professional ministry.  I made my kids come to the church activities and I pressed my spouse into service.  Whenever I went to interview for a new job, my family had to be interviewed too.

I was raised in a minister’s home and so I never thought it inappropriate for a church to have expectations of the preacher’s family.  But it was pointed out to me recently that no other organization can expect an employee’s family to participate in his or her profession.

A few of my churches treated my wife and children decently but most of the years were grim for the family, where they were used up with little recognition. I’m angry at myself for allowing it.  If I had it to do over, I would tell my family that I did not expect them to participate in any church activities—worship, classes, potlucks, VBS, etc—unless they wanted to.  And I would tell my church leadership not to expect anything of them.

To all my minister friends, I encourage you to do what I failed to do and protect your families. Release them from obligation to participate in your profession with you.

 

See David Mercer’s new website:  damercerlife.com

 

The Meaning of Stardust

I did my first nonreligious funeral yesterday. 

In my final two years of formal ministry, I didn’t believe in heaven or hell but my audience did and I wasn’t going to open up a debate in the funeral chapel. It became increasingly difficult to stay within the parameters of Christian sentiment so I relied more and more on liturgical texts to get me through the service.

Now I’m writing my own thoughts.  No liturgies. No divinely inspired words.  No oracles of any kind. Just my stuff. 

Here’s what came to me yesterday:

20151219_205424
photo by David Mercer

I’m told that all matter comes from stardust. For a moment in time, tiny space particles  came together to make something extraordinary–a human being.  I suggest that this body has changed form and has come a step closer to its original oneness with the universe. I wonder what new life will be formed next from these remains.

And what will we make of the remainder of our lives? 

I spent a lot of decades coming to the conclusion that everything that happens in our lives–our losses and gains, sadness and happiness, success and failure, hatred and love–has only the meaning we make of it using our perspective, wisdom, and practice. We take what has occurred up to this moment and use it to give meaning to the next one.

“I used to say, “Ashes to ashes and dust to dust” 

Now I say, “Stardust to stardust and moment to moment.”  

The Fog is Lifting

Road on the plainsState-Route-325-1024x768

The sky was clear but my mind was in a fog as I drove across the plains of northwest Oklahoma.  I had just passed my last interview and was headed home. Later in the spring the Bishop would lay his hands on my head during a special worship service and I would be fully ordained in the United Methodist Church.  I had worked so hard for this that I should have been happy.

I mean, I was happy. Really. I think. 

Okay, I was confused.  

I had been a pastor for another more conservative denomination when I transferred to the United Methodist Church.  Although I didn’t qualify for full ordination I could still serve at a small congregation while I completed my credentials.

It took nine years

It takes a lot of effort, education, and aggravation to become fully ordained in the United Methodist Church.  While I worked full time at the church, I also worked on my Master of Divinity, which is twice the size of most master’s degrees (85 credit hours). Then there’s a three year period of examinations, questionnaires, readings, interviews, and an intense psychological profile.

Many people wash out, but I didn’t stop until I was done.  

Like I said, when I was done, I found myself confused.  I should have been pleased but I found myself falling into depression. Eventually, I shook it off and focused on my pastoral duties.

But another nine years have gone by now.

Earlier this week, after a leave of absence, I wrote to the Bishop and my District Superintendent and relinquished my hard won credentials.

I didn’t leave because I was hurt or angry. I didn’t leave because the church is full of flawed people. I didn’t leave over the conflicts that threaten to divide the denomination. I didn’t leave because I was failing at the work.

I left because I finally admitted to myself that I don’t believe God exists.

I tried so hard. Life would have been much easier if I just continued to force myself to believe.

But I couldn’t. 

I still love the people to whom I ministered. I got angry with them at times but the last thing I ever wanted was to hurt them. I still care for them. I still want to help. I miss them.

I just can’t believe with them. 

It has been a long time but the fog is lifting.

Mirror Mirror

I wrote an anonymous blog for several years called “Clergy Guy,” and it chronicled my thoughts and struggles. I’ve taken it off line and don’t know what to do with it, but I came across this entry from five years ago that I’ll share with you.  It’s about meeting my friend Larry Stevens who goes around the country singing gospel hymns mostly for nursing homes and small churches.  I met him when I was exhausted and sad. He was kind to me without knowing any details. 

I’ve edited the original post a bit.

****************

December 10, 2013

A guy showed up at the nursing home just as I was about to begin worship time. I thought he was a street person because of the worn clothes and uncut hair, but he explained that he traveled from town to town singing gospel songs to nursing home residents.  He showed me his beautiful Martin guitar that a friend gave it to him in support of his ministry. In fact he has several friends who regularly support him in his work. 

I was glad he showed up because I was very tired that day and didn’t feel like singing, so I invited him to do his thing.

He played for them for about an hour, singing the old hymns like I do, telling the same really old jokes and stories that I always tell. At the end he went to all the resident, shaking their hands and patting their shoulders, just like I do.

He held the hand of one nursing home resident and beamed into her face, and she looked over at me and said, “Pastor, he’s a lot like you!” I looked again and he did resemble me a little.

After I arranged to have a hotel room provided for him that night, I took him to lunch and bought us hamburgers. While we ate, he asked about my family. I told him we had two teenage boys. He asked if they ever gave me any problems.  I said no, that they had been free of trouble, made straight As and always made me proud.

“I wish I could claim credit for them,” I said, “But the truth is that they were born this way.”  

I always say that, but this time I went on and told him the rest of the story. “The fact is I haven’t done enough for them.  I’ve left them alone too much. I’ve worked too much, and been too tired to do much for them.”

My throat closed and my eyes filled up. I never told anyone that part. He reached up and put his hand on my shoulder without saying anything–the same exact gesture I had done for countless people. 

I looked at him some more.  He and I shared the same crinkly smile lines around sad eyes.  I could see the same dimples that people say I have behind the beard. He was almost the same size as me (which is substantial), and he had an easy manner which is how I appear to most people. He’s even diabetic like me. 

It felt like I was looking in a mirror at an image of me that was five years older than I am now. And I got to wondering if he actually was me, sent from the near future to bless me enough to keep me from cracking up….

*******************

It is five years later. At the time I thought it might be nice to simply leave my present life and travel down the road singing for people like he did.  But in fact our paths have gone separate ways as have our beliefs.  I’m hoping that he is happy where he is going, as am I. 

This is Larry Stevens and me: 

Larry Stevens and me
David Mercer and Larry Stevens

Larry Stevens is still doing his thing only he expanded his travels to include Israel and Australia.  He chronicles his travels at  https://larryeugenestevens.blogspot.com/