The Weakness of the Cross

Behind the talk of God’s love lurks the shame and anxiety that has always been the driving force of church.  Tonight’s Good Friday service will once again hammer home the gory details of the crucifixion. People will weep and nod in solemn agreement that it was their own sinfulness that caused Jesus’ agony.

We use the story to tap into the shame and anxiety that most of us harbor inside ourselves all the time. And we’ll use it to motivate ourselves to do good deeds.

But there’s a problem and it’s a big one. 

Shame and fear do not promote nobility. They make us sick with an anguish that fosters addiction, and corruption. They further lead us to conceal these miseries so that we can’t face ourselves and make our corrections. 

Church is the place where people are scared to really face themselves. On Sundays, with few exceptions, they won’t talk about the things that keep them up late at night with fear and shame.  Instead, they put on their nice clothes, plaster smiles on their faces, and talk about how blessed they are.  And perhaps they whisper to each other the terrible secrets their neighbors are harboring.

People will read this and feel defensive. Or perhaps they’ll feel shame because they’ll recognize the truth of what I’m saying and blame themselves for it.  But it’s not their fault.

The problem is systemic with no specific person to blame.  Church can’t be a place for openness and healing when its basic premise is that people are awful sinners who caused the death of God’s child. 

We need a safe place where there is no pressure, where people are loved with softness, and humanity is celebrated with quiet joy. Wouldn’t it be amazing if there were a place where people could freely air their true worries and flaws, where they could help each other with authentic words of comfort and encouragement?

Too bad we can’t find that at church. 

An Awful Power

She was lonely and grieving. She came to the revival because she needed… something. 

The speaker noticed the attractive blonde sitting by herself in the crowd, eyes wide and glistening, and her head bobbing at everything he said.  He caught her eye again and again during the sermon, staring just a beat longer than necessary. 

When he gave his invitation he said, “The Holy Spirit has a special word for someone tonight.” (She nodded).  “This person has been waiting a long time to hear from God.” (nod, nod). “This person has been separated from God because of SIN, but tonight is her time to RELEASE all that holds her back.” (nod, stifled sob).

Then he stepped off the podium and slowly walked up the aisle, pointing his finger at my friend.

“Sister!” he continued with building volume, “Won’t you allow the Spirit of the Lord to enter in and make his dwelling in your heart?”

Tears streamed down her face as she cried, “Yes, Yes, Oh yes!”

Then he did that thing that Pentecostal ministers do where he placed his hand on her forehead and she collapsed.  Two big deacons had placed themselves behind her and caught her as she fell.   The preacher moved onto his next victim.

Nothing mystical or spiritual happened here. The preacher’s practiced eye had seen a vulnerable person and to make the show more dramatic he took advantage.

It’s a form of rape.

In addition to vulnerable ones like her, shills placed throughout the audience are cued to fall at the preacher’s touch. Then the power of suggestion takes over and plenty of people will keel over, too. They have no idea they are being manipulated.  

It happens every Sunday in churches all over the world. 

I’m frustrated that people allow themselves to be so easily controlled. And it makes me angry that someone would use the pulpit to manipulate and brutalize others.   

When I was a pastor I never practiced that “faith healing” crap. I was always aware of the power people gave me and I tried not to harm them.  I didn’t scream, accuse, or manipulate people. I didn’t claim any special word from on high. And I didn’t let the music go on and on, holding the church hostage until someone came forward to be “saved.”

Yet even with my muted style, I could see people looking at me, waiting for a holy message to make them feel less desperate. It disturbed me to be given so much power.

Want to know a secret? I used to feel inadequate and embarrassed that I got so few responses from my sermons. But now I’m glad I was a failure.

I was never comfortable taking on the “Man of God” role, showing a confidence I didn’t feel, demonstrating a faith that was never so firm as my voice.  I hoped one day to grow into it the role but instead I grew out of it. It only took me thirty-five years.

I have many minister friends who are humble and want only to help.  But the culture in which we function compels us to wield way too much power where people will accept anything we say without critical examination. It’s one of the dynamics that allows many religious leaders to get caught up in scandal.  

I still want to help those who are lonely and grieving but now I do it as one person to another, with no magic tricks, no gimmicks, and no power trips.   

Our True Religion: Football, Firearms, and the American Flag

People often mix various aspects of their culture into their religion and call it Christianity.

 

The 2nd Amendment Isn’t In the Bible 

I remember once at prayer time that I asked the congregation what they were thankful for. A young man spoke of how grateful he was for the nice turnout they’d had at the NRA rally the day before. He said it was a lovely family occasion with a potluck dinner where the kids played. Best of all, his wife won a handgun with… and I’m not kidding here… pink grips.

To make it even more bizarre, everyone in church broke into spontaneous applause at the news.  I was disconcerted but I consoled myself that at least we weren’t as extreme as a Baptist church I’d heard of that had its own gun show in their “Family Life Center.”

I grew up in Texas where guns are a part of the culture. I’ve always liked them. But even when I was mired in my conservative evangelical mindset, I was disturbed at how deeply our love for guns was embedded in our religion. In some ways the NRA was our denomination and the 2nd amendment was holy scripture.

But let’s move on to other things.

High school football, for instance

 

Set… Hut… Amen! 

I remember that our coach stopped going to church because he would be grilled in his pew over the previous game, especially if our team lost… and that happened pretty often.  I also remember an occasion where the lay leader prayed over “our boys,” thanking the Almighty for “how they had showed themselves to be men” even though they’d lost (again) but this time by only one touchdown.

Friday night football was (and still is) their true worship service.

I could say so much more but let’s move on to patriotism.

 

I Pledge Allegiance To…. 

In some churches where I was a minister our most powerful services were not at Easter or Christmas but rather the ones that recognized national holidays.  The Sunday before the 4th of July we would sing patriotic hymns and people would stand misty-eyed, perhaps saluting the country’s flag that hung all year in the front of the sanctuary. 

I remain a proud citizen of the United States of America. But patriotism and religion need to stay separated in our minds as well as our churches, schools and government offices. Christianity is dead wrong to use political muscle to force our beliefs onto people through legislation. Christianity’s history shows this to be true. Remember our own religious wars? When we mix nationalism with our beliefs we can make an unholy mess.

You don’t have to be a Christian to be a good citizen.  Atheists, Muslims, Wiccans, Hindus, Buddhists, Pantheists, Unitarians, etc… they can all be good Americans.  But you can’t be a true “Christian” if you combine all your opinions to make one big superstitious mix.

If you follow Jesus you might want to remember that he wasn’t an American citizen, he didn’t play football, and he damn sure didn’t own a gun.      

Ash Wednesday, Mass Shooting, and Valentines

A few days ago, many Christians observed Ash Wednesday service. It’s a pivotal day between Christmas and Easter when Christians get serious with their self examination. The clergyperson uses ashes mixed with oil and makes the sign of the cross on the forehead of the participant, accompanied by the words, “From dust you came. To dust you will return.”

It’s a time when people are supposed to recognize and repent of their sins. It’s also a time to reflect on their mortality. Immediately following Ash Wednesday is the forty day period called Lent where people prepare themselves for the Easter season by fasting and reflection. Of course, you shouldn’t really go without eating for that long so people decide to give up specific things like chocolate, caffeine, or Facebook.

When I was a minister, I gave it a light touch and I told everyone I was giving up kumquats and pilates for Lent.

I’m no psychologist but it always seemed to me that periods of extreme self denial did not inspire real improvement. Addicts will often deny themselves for short intervals just to prove to themselves that they’re in control, and then they go right back to their destructive behavior. It was also my experience that Christians already focused on their sins and inadequacies all the time and I questioned whether it was necessary to make it an official occasion.

Over time, people invented another occasion just before Ash Wednesday where they have big parties or flings of some sort. In New Orleans they have Mardi Gras where people gather for drinking and dancing, and some of the women even flash their boobs to the crowds. Other people all over the world celebrate what they call Fat Tuesday and have their own party time. Some people keep it pretty tame and so they have a tradition of eating a big ole plate of pancakes on that Tuesday (no kidding).

So there you have it. Go out and party big time. Then feel really really bad about it. Repeat the process yearly. Mark your calendar.

I don’t participate anymore although I recognize that people really do have their cycles that lead from celebration to grief to recovery and then hopefully to celebration again. I just don’t think it’s that orderly a process and I don’t think it should be.

Ash Wednesday fell on Valentine’s Day this year. I’m not really sure how people blended their ashes with hearts and flowers. I was substitute teaching at a high school and it was a festive day where girls had styled their hair and wore fancy red dresses and high heels. They carried cards, candy, flowers, balloons, and giant stuffed animals that hopeful boys had bestowed upon them. I enjoyed it.

But the next day was quite different. The laughter and chatter from the day before was gone and the kids trudged to their classes in silence. The classes were quiet, too. I had no trouble keeping order and I found I didn’t care too much for the change.

The afternoon before–on Valentine’s Day/Ash Wednesday, a young man had gone into a school downstate from us and used an assault weapon to kill seventeen students and teachers, wounding many more. Videos showed us bodies and we heard gunfire and screams. There were armed police, flashing lights, and crying parents….

We have entered a season of shock and mourning where we’re forced to consider the fact that life really is short (much too short for some). We really need to think about the evil we inflict on each other and consider ways to stop it.

I wish we could do more with this time than blame each other, defend our political positions, and ultimately accomplish nothing. There’s no way to avoid grief and unhappiness so we might as well put it to use and do the work that will bring us to a better state of existence.

And if we really need a set a calendar to begin the process, let’s start with today.

Christmas: A Story that Cannot be Ignored

Christmas is a lovely holiday but the image we have of Jesus’ birth is somewhat different from the biblical accounts.

There’s no innkeeper—I think we invented him so we could have one more part for a kid to play in the pageant. And believe it or not, there was no stable with cute animals and sweet smelling hay.  We say the child was wrapped in “swaddling clothes” which sounds beautiful but they were really just rags. “Manger” is also a pleasant word but it was just a dirty feedbox kept outside for the livestock. 

So here’s the real picture: a child was born outside in the dirt at night. His parents were far from home away from any family support. Add to that the element of scandal where the kid’s identity was questioned–(Who was his daddy?) 

So far, this is not a unique story.  Even today, children are born in these conditions and many of them, as well as their mothers, die anonymously in poverty.

But this story takes a different turn.  Angels appeared in the sky and sang of his arrival to shepherds, who in turn went to the child and bowed to him in worship. Astrologers from another land searched the skies and used a star to guide them on a two year journey to find this child and give him lavish gifts.

The boy grew up to be a teacher, a healer, and a leader.  When his enemies killed him, it is said he didn’t stay dead. Today, people claim that he is the redeemer of humanity. 

It may only be a story but it can’t be ignored because it has a message of powerful hope.  When all the various forms of Christianity are combined, they make up the world’s biggest religion.    

For several years I held onto the image of God as a baby when nothing else made any sense to me.  Now I’ve come to believe that there is something special, maybe even sacred, in all children. They bring out our our noblest ambitions and our best efforts. I think the children of the world constantly redeem humanity (Let’s face it, the world needs constant redeeming.) It makes sense to me that we would tell each other a story about a child who grew up to save the world.

Anyway, whether or not we believe it… Merry Christmas.

What Is God’s Plan For Me?

What is God’s plan for me?

I’ve asked this question all my life and have never gotten an answer.   Has anybody? 

Not a Bible quote. Not a cryptic message. Not a “sign.” Not a “prompting of the spirit.” Not your own private thought. Not a friend’s strongly expressed opinion. But a clear, unequivocal directive from the Almighty.  

Some claim that they have, but usually they’re pretty subjective.  And on the rare occasion when someone tells me that God actually spoke directly to them, I see haunted eyes glazed over with denial, and I have a hard time believing them.

Most people who are trying to honor God with their actions commit to a lot of study and prayer, then take their best guess as to what God has in mind. And if it doesn’t work out, well then it must have been their fault. They didn’t pray hard enough, or have enough faith, or their hearts weren’t right, or they overlooked the fine print.  Then they would repent, try even harder and be even more careful. 

If we repeat that process enough times we become unable to function.   

Even before I stopped believing altogether, I acknowledged that God never answered my questions so I decided to start taking responsibility for my own actions.  I wouldn’t wait forever for instruction, and I wouldn’t stop at each step, look up for affirmation, and hope I was getting it right.

“We don’t know what God has in mind for you,” I would advise my parishioners. “The only thing you can know for sure is what YOU will do next. So get clear on that.”

Few people liked that answer but it was the only one I had.  It helped me to move forward and stop second guessing myself. 

Whether they believe in God or not, I encourage everyone to take full responsibility for their own actions. Make your decisions, correct your mistakes, and keep moving forward.

I Won’t Stay Quiet

David, you’re hurting the church.  Why can’t you just be quiet?

I’ve been told all my life to be quiet for the sake of the church. Sure, I can preach, teach, guide, and help. But don’t challenge anyone or ask questions or express doubts because it hurts the church and I’ll go to hell Plus I could lose my job.

How do my words hurt anyone? The church claims to be an instrument of truth. How do people find truth if they are not allowed to ask, seek, and knock? Is the institution really so fragile that it can’t handle my voicing my thoughts?

When I was a young preacher in the churches of Christ, they taught that instrumental music in worship was evil. I thought it was ridiculous but I had to be careful with my words or I could lose my job. Later, I learned to refrain from voicing a dissenting opinion on baptism in the United Methodist church because I wanted to keep my job. For the same reason, I also kept quiet about much bigger issues, including our relationship with the LGBTQIA.

Yet job security was rarely mentioned. Instead, we spoke of how damaged the church could be if we even brought up these subjects. It’s interesting that an institution with the power to affect my life so dramatically could be so fragile.

Now, I’m still being urged to stay quiet. But I’m not going to. Silence makes us sick. It can even kill. I always wanted to be a healer so I’ll continue to speak up.

I’ll try to be respectful and reasonable. Just not quiet.

What Do I Call Myself?

It’s hard to find the words to describe myself.

Am I a nonbeliever? An agnostic? A heretic?  An infidel?  These terms suggest that I have lost my identity and am reacting erratically  like a bouncing pinball. But I haven’t lost myself. I’m growing up.

 “What happened that made you lose your faith?” asked a friend. 

There was no one event.  Others like me have said it is like “dying from a thousand cuts,” meaning that it happened gradually.

I remember the first time I seriously questioned my belief nearly two decades ago. I was sick and unhappy, and I prayed hard for help.  I didn’t need much–just some kind of reassurance, some indication that the loving God about whom I preached was really there.  It never happened.  How could I not question his existence?  With the exception of one friend, everyone shushed me and told me not to let my mind entertain doubts. 

I did what they told me. I decided that no matter what, I would continue to believe. I continued to develop my career as a minister. I went back to school and got my Master of Divinity.  When I felt doubt I told myself what I told other people: “You still have a choice.”

I chose to believe until I gave up. 

You know what? I lost some friends, a career, and a marriage, but life didn’t end for me. It started to get better.  I started to grow rather than diminish.  A year later, I have a little more peace and feel a little less broken. I have love and happiness. I have new thoughts and new opportunities. 

So back to the question: What do I call myself?

That’s easy.  I am David

What Will Happen When I Die?

What happens to us after this life? I’m dying to know….

My consciousness… that presence behind the eyes that processes my thoughts and experiences–does it drift away and go somewhere else?   Does it turn off with a small blip like the screen of a computer? Is it like sleep where the consciousness relaxes and simply lets go so it can live in its dreams? Does it ever awaken again?

As I get older and the physical brain atrophies will there actually be less identity or will it still be there fully formed, gradually imprisoned a small increment at a time, subject to slower blood flow and fragile brain cells ? When the body comes to a full stop, will the mind be released to return to its complete version, or will it simply fire one last synapse before it’s gone?

What happens when a body comes to a sudden violent stop? Does the consciousness disappear instantly, or does it wander about like someone who lost everything when a tornado destroys her home in an instant?

When I see the body of a loved one at a funeral, I find myself watching for the chest to rise and fall, allowing myself a small hope that maybe it has all been a mistake and the person is still alive.  It’s nearly impossible to accept that a life simply ceases.  But there doesn’t seem to be proof one way or the other about an afterlife unless we accept the accounts of people who were technically unalive and then brought back.  Is there really a bright light for us to go toward where people wait to welcome us? What about those of us who are sure we’ve seen loved ones after their deaths? About half of those surveyed say they have experienced this. Do we discount those reports simply because we don’t understand how it could be true?

Is there another state of existence? Those interested in quantum physics have been discussing the idea of different dimensions existing within each other, but it’s becoming passé these days.   Others say that our individuality fades into a collective consciousness.  Perhaps that’s what Jesus was trying to say when he prayed, “May we all be one, Father… I in thee, and thee in me, and they in us.”

Or is it all just a physical and chemical thing, where the life impulse dies when the body succumbs to the law of entropy and becomes integrated with the rest of the earth, and the only reincarnation is when the atoms come together again in a reformation of life? I have to admit that’s kind of amazing.

All I know is that this life is passing quickly which sometimes fills me with an urgency to make everything count while I still exist. Other times, I remember to be less urgent and simply enjoy each moment. Often, I am filled with relief to know that one day I’ll be finished. I will have done my best but now I get to stop. And if it is a matter of simply blinking out of existence, that’s okay with me.

Hell: NO!

Tis the season for Halloween.  Many churches object to the holiday, calling it satanic, yet at the same time, some of those churches will offer alternatives that are truly satanic. Their haunted houses (often called, “Hell House”) offer images of hell complete with fire, demons, and torture. You know, fun for the whole family. 

Did you know the word for hell is not in the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) at all? It’s only mentioned once in the New Testament (2 Peter 2:4).  A few other verses speak of something we assume refers to hell but there’s a lot of room for discussion about it. 

Our concept of hell comes from Dante or perhaps Milton and we’ve added to it over the centuries.  We’ve certainly used it to frighten and control people, especially the children, and that troubles me greatly. Fear of hell was always a rotten motivator, however it can stoke the general anxiety of people.  

I always soft pedaled the eternal punishment part of my preaching even in my early period when I was a conservative fundamentalist.  A few years back I quit believing the church’s teaching on it because it just didn’t hold up theologically.  In my final years, I did not speak of it at all from the pulpit and I quietly told individuals that my thoughts had changed on the subject.

I observe that hell has lost a lot of its fire these days.  It doesn’t appear to scare us so much anymore, which suits me fine.