“When you were young, we were so proud. You grew up in our church. You knew the answers in Sunday school. You sang the hymns. You were baptized at the proper age of twelve. Later, you went to the youth gatherings and said the sweetest prayers. We watched you go off to Bible college and we knew you’d become a fine little preacher.
“What happened to you? Did we do something to cause you to fall away?”
Well… Let me put it to you this way:
You said to pray every day, and I did. But when I whispered to you that it didn’t seem like anyone was listening, you said to try harder, so I did, and it didn’t help.
You said to study the Bible, and I did. But when I became an expert in biblical studies and told you that the Bible said things you never told me about, you were indignant.
You said to tell the truth, and I did. But you didn’t like hearing something other than what you’d always heard and so you urged me to hush before I got into trouble.
You said to love the unlovely, and I did. But I found that you didn’t mean the homeless, and Blacks and Hispanics and those homosexuals.
You ask what happened to me. The answer is I did what you told me to do. In some ways, I still do.
“Now hold on, you can’t blame us. We never claimed to be perfect but it’s not our fault that you fell from the one true way. You have to take responsibility for your own actions. You have to think for yourself.”
I do. My life is my own. You don’t have to take any blame for how I turned out.
I wrote an anonymous blog for several years called “Clergy Guy,” and it chronicled my thoughts and struggles. I’ve taken it off line and don’t know what to do with it, but I came across this entry from five years ago that I’ll share with you. It’s about meeting my friend Larry Stevens who goes around the country singing gospel hymns mostly for nursing homes and small churches. I met him when I was exhausted and sad. He was kind to me without knowing any details.
I’ve edited the original post a bit.
****************
December 10, 2013
A guy showed up at the nursing home just as I was about to begin worship time. I thought he was a street person because of the worn clothes and uncut hair, but he explained that he traveled from town to town singing gospel songs to nursing home residents. He showed me his beautiful Martin guitar that a friend gave it to him in support of his ministry. In fact he has several friends who regularly support him in his work.
I was glad he showed up because I was very tired that day and didn’t feel like singing, so I invited him to do his thing.
He played for them for about an hour, singing the old hymns like I do, telling the same really old jokes and stories that I always tell. At the end he went to all the resident, shaking their hands and patting their shoulders, just like I do.
He held the hand of one nursing home resident and beamed into her face, and she looked over at me and said, “Pastor, he’s a lot like you!” I looked again and he did resemble me a little.
After I arranged to have a hotel room provided for him that night, I took him to lunch and bought us hamburgers. While we ate, he asked about my family. I told him we had two teenage boys. He asked if they ever gave me any problems. I said no, that they had been free of trouble, made straight As and always made me proud.
“I wish I could claim credit for them,” I said, “But the truth is that they were born this way.”
I always say that, but this time I went on and told him the rest of the story. “The fact is I haven’t done enough for them. I’ve left them alone too much. I’ve worked too much, and been too tired to do much for them.”
My throat closed and my eyes filled up. I never told anyone that part. He reached up and put his hand on my shoulder without saying anything–the same exact gesture I had done for countless people.
I looked at him some more. He and I shared the same crinkly smile lines around sad eyes. I could see the same dimples that people say I have behind the beard. He was almost the same size as me (which is substantial), and he had an easy manner which is how I appear to most people. He’s even diabetic like me.
It felt like I was looking in a mirror at an image of me that was five years older than I am now. And I got to wondering if he actually was me, sent from the near future to bless me enough to keep me from cracking up….
*******************
It is five years later. At the time I thought it might be nice to simply leave my present life and travel down the road singing for people like he did. But in fact our paths have gone separate ways as have our beliefs. I’m hoping that he is happy where he is going, as am I.
This is Larry Stevens and me:
David Mercer and Larry Stevens
Larry Stevens is still doing his thing only he expanded his travels to include Israel and Australia. He chronicles his travels athttps://larryeugenestevens.blogspot.com/
It’s a reflex and I’m not the only one that has it.
I was sitting in the crowded waiting room at the doctor’s office. I may have been ill but I don’t really remember why I was there. Whether or not I was sick, I was definitely tired.
When I heard the thud of someone falling, my head was bowed and my eyes were closed, but I had heard that sound before and I knew someone was down.
I was out of my chair and moving in an instant and I was halfway across the room before I opened my eyes. It’s a wonder I didn’t stumble and fall myself. I focused in on the man who had fallen. Fortunately, he was okay and was already getting himself up so I went back to my seat.
I like this about myself–that reflex to help which kicks in even when I’m down.
I have left behind many things: my career, friends, my faith. But I still have that reflex. It comes from deep within my identity, molded by upbringing and training. I may or may not continue to have the professional title of minister but it’s a core part of my personality. It’s not just what I do. It’s what I am and what I’ll always be.
Perhaps now that I am not so tired and sick, I can be even more effective at it.
Jesus replied, “Very truly I tell you, no one can see the kingdom of God unless they are born again.”
“How can someone be born when they are old?” Nicodemus asked. “Surely they cannot enter a second time into their mother’s womb to be born!”
“You are Israel’s teacher,” said Jesus, “and do you not understand these things?”
–John 3:3-4, 10 (NIV).
————————————————–
We followed mirages,
And fought over their reality.
I tried to help carry others
But now I don’t.
I stumble forward by myself…
—————————————————-
We brought in an enthusiastic speaker to get us revved up. He spoke our old beliefs as if they were brand new. He was funny, positive, and spoke in a rhythmic cadence that invited us to shout our hallelujahs and amens.
“Turn to your neighbor and say, ‘Jesus is ALIVE!’” And everyone did but me.
Later, a friend asked me “What did you think of it?”
“I think everything we said tonight was exactly the same as what we said in the 1970s, only we’re all grayer and slower.”
“Maybe we need to be reminded to go back to our old ways,” my friend suggested.
Maybe our old ways led to our decline,” I countered.
Jesus once said that we must be born again. He didn’t mean that we needed to return to infantile ways or to go back to do it all again the same way. I think he was saying to let go of the old ways and become something that we have never been before. We need to reach higher planes of awareness by thinking new thoughts and dreaming new dreams.
But we’re not doing that. We never have. The church has always expended most of its energy in staying exactly the same, keeping the same beliefs intact, and repeating the same activities. In fact, people will fight hard against newness and they hurt those who challenge the church effectively.
Why?
Why isn’t the church a champion for creativity, experimentation, and innovation? Why didn’t we celebrate Copernicus and Galileo? Why aren’t we more curious about scientific discovery? Why aren’t we leading the way in social change?
I don’t know. And to tell the truth, I’m losing interest in analyzing why we’ve failed. I’m only interested in moving forward, even if it’s by myself.
The apostle Paul once said that we were baptized to walk in newness of life. But we are scared to do it. It’s much easier to march toward death while insisting we are right.
If by politics, we mean communicating, negotiating, and even persuading each other… well, those are good things. It makes sense to engage in them because a church depends on people working together in a mature, respectful fashion. In the best circumstances, there can be disagreement, flared tempers, and hurt feelings but they are resolved when people practice open, caring communication.
However, when we speak of church politics, we usually refer to those who gossip and manipulate to get their way. Some are looking to impede change. Others entertain themselves by assassinating the reputation of persons. Then there’s that special cadre dedicated to undermining the preacher with the ultimate goal being to get rid of him or her. Sometimes these people cling to leadership positions; others prefer to stay hidden, doing their work with whispered conversations.
Much as I wanted to, I couldn’t ignore them. I also couldn’t negotiate with them because they couldn’t tolerate the openness of honest discussion. As a result, I spent too much energy protecting myself and others. It was easier when leadership protected me but that meant they couldn’t focus their energy on anything else either.
Every church I’ve known since childhood has this dysfunctional element. Every minister I know describes similar dysfunctions. No wonder membership continues to decline–although they’re not the only reason for it.
To the surviving handful of people who tried so hard to get rid of me over the last three decades, feel free to claim your victory. Congratulations… I’m out. However, I didn’t leave because of you.
… (T)he truth of the matter is, you do not get to call generation after generation of LGBTQUI people sinful and make them 2nd class citizens with deadly words wrapped up in an abusive definition of love and then cry foul when someone tells you to stop it.” (Pat Green).*
He’s right. Want to start a fight that can only end in surrender or destruction? Attack a man’s child.
Go ahead. Tell the children that their sexuality is sinful, that their feelings are disgusting and should be repressed. Ridicule them. Tell jokes about them. Tell them they shouldn’t exist. Stand by and let them be bullied, beaten, and violated. Watch them die of illness and suicide, then say it’s their own fault, and tell them they’ll be in hell once they’re gone.
Do you really expect their loved ones to stand by and let you get away with that?
You can say, “Hey, I’m just quoting God and calling sin what it is. What’s wrong with that? I don’t hate the sinner. I hate the sin.”
I say that’s a lie and that you’re bullying others while hiding behind your religion.
You can back away and talk about how angry the queers are and be shocked at their naughty language. After all, you are only trying to show God’s love. You can even talk about how you’re being persecuted for expressing your religious views. Oh, and be sure to puff up and talk about how you believe in the Bible as if that gives you free reign to be hateful. After all, the Bible is God’s word.
Frankly, I’m amazed at how you can be sarcastic, condescending, and delusional at the same time. It’s not gay people who are twisted. You are.
I’m upset but to be honest, my feelings are not directed primarily at you. I’m angry and ashamed at myself for standing by and not speaking up before.
When I was a kid I daydreamed of being a hero who saved people from the bad guys. But when I was a teenager, I stayed silent when others bullied a slender soft spoken kid because I didn’t want anyone to think I was gay, too. When I became a minister I saw myself as a defender of oppressed people. However, I wanted to be considerate and not offend my parishioners, hoping that I could gently guide them away from their rage. As I got older I continued to be diplomatic because I didn’t want to endanger my ministerial pension.
Finally, now that I’m past the midpoint of my lifespan, I’m speaking up. In my last post, I tried to be kind but I guess I can’t expect people to take it well when I say they’re wrong. Some did, but others weren’t able to stay civil. It’s okay, I’m not scared of their rage anymore.
I am however, more resolved. And I’m putting people on notice that I’m standing up and speaking out.
*Pat Green is the author of Transparent Expedition, a blog about being the parent of a transgender child.
I was in seminary, focused on the skull cracking material of our Constructive Theology class, when I felt something bounce lightly off my head and land on my open book. It was a peanut. I already knew who did it because this was a regular occurrence. I turned to see a woman giggling quietly and it made the whole room a little lighter. Later, she laughed more loudly while she told everyone, “I am throwing peanuts at this BEAUTIFUL man….”
She’s cheerful, kind, and calls me “dear” with her lovely Colombian accent. Everyone loves her and feels better around her. She radiates grace.
One time in another class, a fellow student had a medical emergency, and she was the first to respond. She put her arms around the woman and said softly, “Don’t worry. I will take care of you.” And she helped our friend find the medicine she needed.
She is a minister to her core and I am proud she is my colleague. Yet she is not qualified to be ordained in most denominations. Being a woman disqualifies her in many, but even in my more progressive United Methodist denomination she is not accepted because she is a lesbian. She is, however, a minister for another organization which is to their benefit.
There really aren’t that many kind, uplifting ministers out there, and any church that wouldn’t want her is making a mistake from which they will not recover. I’m serious about that—they will not recover.
My denomination teeters on the edge of a devastating split over how we regard members of the GLBT. There’s a great deal of nuanced discussion as well as bellicose arguing. Frankly, I’ve become sick of it. I’m also ashamed that I haven’t spoken up enough on behalf of my GLBT friends.
I moved from a conservative evangelical community to the more progressive United Methodists because they were kind to me and because they were open and more welcoming than other Christians I had known. They taught me to think more clearly and to care about social justice issues. And yet they have not been able to move forward to resolve this discussion.
They are not going to find an honorable compromise because this is an issue of right and wrong. And the majority of the UMC is wrong. The majority thinks any kind of sex other than hetero is sinful. They won’t allow them ordination or provide wedding ceremonies for them.
I want to be respectful, so I’ll say it softly with no exclamation points at the end of the sentence:
If you discriminate, judge against, exclude, or hurt people because they are in the GLBT community, I respectfully say that you are wrong. And you should change. Not only should you change your thinking but you need to focus on healing those who are in pain.
Last week, I began to volunteer some time to The Center in Orlando. It exists to promote the well being of GLBT community of Central Florida. There’s a great deal of healing that needs to occur and I intend to be a part of that.