What I Said Then; What I Say Now

I was at a retirement home, giving my thoughts on a passage of scripture.  They knew I had once been a minister and that I now no longer believed. 

A woman asked me, “What would you say if your child asked you, “Did Jesus really walk on water? Did he really feed five thousand people? Would you tell them that it really happened just as it exactly as it says in the Bible? 

I took a moment to gather my thoughts.

“When my children were little,” I said,  “I did tell them that I thought it happened just as it said in the bible because back then I did believe. However, I would answer differently today.  I’d say something like… ‘Many good people believe these things really happened. However, it doesn’t seem likely that these things could occur. So, no, I don’t believe they did.’”

She nodded… accepting my answer, which was good because it was the only one I had.

A year or so before I left Christianity and was still wrestling with my beliefs, I taught a confirmation class for the young teens in my church. I reviewed church teachings with them and I talked about heaven, forgiveness, and the salvation through Jesus Christ.

I can still say what I said then:

“Your parents baptized you when you were little and raised you to hear the teachings of the church. But confirmation is your chance to take ownership of your thoughts and beliefs.  Nobody can make you. Not your parents. Not me. Even God won’t.” 

They all chose to go ahead with the ceremony because, in truth, they were still too young to decide for themselves. Evaluation of family beliefs usually happens during the college years when they are being trained to think critically for themselves. That’s when they start deciding for themselves what they believe.

I have always shied away from telling people what they HAVE to believe.  I still do.

On the other hand, I’m more than happy to say what I think is true, and I will argue strenuously with grownups who know (or should know) how to think for themselves. 

If I Had Stayed Then, I Would Have to Leave Now

I didn’t leave the United Methodists because of my divorce. I didn’t leave because I was angry with the people.  I left because my beliefs changed. 

It was hard to leave because I love the United Methodist Church. 

Twenty years ago, I got sick and was in the hospital.  I was a minister in another denomination at the time, but it was a United Methodist minister who came to sit with me, and it was my United Methodist friends who came to cheer me up.  And it was the United Methodist minister’s wife who coordinated food and sitters so my wife could come visit me.  For the next several months as I slowly recuperated at home, both United Methodist Churches in that town sent me notes of encouragement, saying they were praying for me. 

Consequently, I transferred to the United Methodist Church as soon as I could. While I worked for them, they helped me go back to school to get my master’s degree.  With their support I became an Elder in Full Connection, and I was very proud. 

If I could have held onto my faith I would still be with them. But if I had stayed then, I would have to leave now because I wouldn’t be able to live with the decisions that are currently being made at the General Conference of 2019. 

For years many had hoped that the UMC would grow to recognize its obligation to fully accept the LGBT.  However, I was not one of them.  I used to be as conservative as they came.  I thought of the LGBT as people living a sinful lifestyle. 

But while I was with the UMC, I read, thought, and grew up.  Consequently, I changed my mind and I came to see them as persons deserving every human right and courtesy. I believed the church as a whole would one day come to this conclusion, too.  But it appears that it’s not going to happen.   

As I said, if I hadn’t left two years ago, I would be leaving now, as many others are planning to do. 

People Are Being Beaten

He was cautious. Forty years ago, life was risky for a gay person. He approached a young acquaintance and asked if he was interested in a sexual encounter. The young man seemed to agree with him and they decided to meet at a deserted location. But when they met, the young man beat the guy.

The young man told his friends about it, bragging about how he had blackened the guy’s eyes, broken his nose, and cracked his ribs. His pals approved figuring the gay guy had it coming.

Forty years later, some progress has been made but it’s still risky for people of the LGBT community. They can still get beaten and in some parts of the world, they’re killed. However even if they don’t risk physical injury, they’re still often targets of ridicule and derision. They’re still regarded as unworthy of equal consideration even if the law says they must be given equal rights.

How would you feel to be regarded as “not normal”?

What if your family was embarrassed about you? How would it feel to be told that living alone was the only honorable path for you? What would you think if your church told you that they loved you “anyway,” even if you are an abomination—and, by the way, those are some of the more tolerant churches. Most churches still blame the LGBT for natural disasters and the fall of civilizations—and I wish I was joking.

It’s a sin, the religious folk say. It goes against the Bible.

I don’t care what the Bible says–they’re wrong. Quoting the Bible and claiming to speak for God makes them even more wrong.

I’ve been hoping the United Methodist Church, the denomination where I served as a minister, would make some changes in their attitude toward the LGBT. They’re going to have an expensive, divisive conference to talk about the ordination of non-heterosexual people and same sex marriage. I’ve only just now realized that no one is going to change their minds. The only thing I see happening is that the LGBT will be more resented afterwards.

I want to shout at my former colleagues: “Come on! We were supposed to be the world changers! We were supposed to be champions of the oppressed!”

Come on!

People are being beaten!

The UMC Is Up At Bat

The United Methodist Church is ripping itself apart over how they will regard members of the LGBT. Because I was a United Methodist Minister for a long time, I have an interest in the direction they will choose, and so I have repeatedly expressed my views and urged them to be fully inclusive.

Before I say anything else about them I should note that at least the UMC is grappling with the issue. The Southern Baptists aren’t . The Assemblies of God aren’t. The Latter Day Saints aren’t. All the little independent fundamentalist churches aren’t.

They’re still intact with their love-the-sinner-hate-the-sin motto. They’re still taking cold comfort in their righteous indignation. They’re still spreading anxiety with a false notion that a people that make up less than five percent of the population are taking away our rights, corrupting everyone’s morals, and causing God to inflict natural disasters on all of us.

So I appreciate the UMC for struggling over this. Sometimes I complain because it’s taking so long but they’re further along than many other Christian organizations. I would love to see the UMC lead the rest of Christianity in taking a small step forward in showing dignity and respect to an oppressed minority.

They are up at bat while the other churches haven’t even made it to the ball field.

man holding baseball bat
Photo by Tim Eiden on Pexels.com

Church Camp

I tried to love church camp like my colleagues claimed to, but I couldn’t. Being away from my family for a week or two, exposed to nature’s bugs, skunks, and snakes, plus sleeping in an unairconditioned cabin with a bunch of preadolescent boys was never my idea of a good time.

Call me a poor sport. Call me a sissy. Just don’t call me to be a camp counselor ever again.

But more importantly than my discomfort, I have some real concerns for the kids that attend.

First, let me say I’ve hesitated to speak about this because I have dear friends who have invested themselves in giving kids good experiences in camp. They have no intention of engineering a manipulative atmosphere as revealed in the documentary, Jesus Camp.  I’ll even agree that many camp leaders, especially in United Methodist camps, are diligent in showing respect for the campers.  Furthermore, many people tell me they have great memories of attending church camp.

I believe them but I’m still concerned. I say that even with the best intentions, there’s a great deal of manipulation happening in church camps.

Tell me I’m wrong… that these elements are not in church camps:

Isolation where young ones are away from home and family.

Sleep deprivation where they wake up early and stay up late.

Exhaustion from physical activities including long hikes.

Indoctrination from the small group sharing sessions, exciting music, emotional storytelling, using scripture like incantations, and pressuring the children to give their hearts to Jesus.

Of course the kids respond to the invitation… sobbing as they stumble up the aisles, offering themselves to God, mistaking their fatigue for spirituality.

I actually helped at these camps, thinking it was good for the kids. But I’ve changed my mind and I’m sorry I was ever a part of them. Again, I don’t think those who led these camps meant to hurt anyone. They were trying to help, to give kids a good experience.

But I still think it’s wrong.

The LGBT–I’m No Longer Standing By

… (T)he truth of the matter is, you do not get to call generation after generation of LGBTQUI people sinful and make them 2nd class citizens with deadly words wrapped up in an abusive definition of love and then cry foul when someone tells you to stop it.” (Pat Green).*

He’s right. Want to start a fight that can only end in surrender or destruction? Attack a man’s child.

Go ahead. Tell the children that their sexuality is sinful, that their feelings are disgusting and should be repressed. Ridicule them. Tell jokes about them. Tell them they shouldn’t exist. Stand by and let them be bullied, beaten, and violated. Watch them die of illness and suicide, then say it’s their own fault, and tell them they’ll be in hell once they’re gone.

Do you really expect their loved ones to stand by and let you get away with that?

You can say, “Hey, I’m just quoting God and calling sin what it is. What’s wrong with that?  I don’t hate the sinner. I hate the sin.”

I say that’s a lie and that you’re bullying others while hiding behind your religion.

You can back away and talk about how angry the queers are and be shocked at their naughty language. After all, you are only trying to show God’s love. You can even talk about how you’re being persecuted for expressing your religious views.  Oh, and be sure to puff up and talk about how you believe in the Bible as if that gives you free reign to be hateful.  After all, the Bible is God’s word.

Frankly, I’m amazed at how you can be sarcastic, condescending, and delusional at the same time. It’s not gay people who are twisted. You are.

I’m upset but to be honest, my feelings are not directed primarily at you.  I’m angry and ashamed at myself for standing by and not speaking up before.

When I was a kid I daydreamed of being a hero who saved people from the bad guys. But when I was a teenager, I stayed silent when others bullied a slender soft spoken kid because I didn’t want anyone to think I was gay, too.  When I became a minister I saw myself as a defender of oppressed people.  However, I wanted to be considerate and not offend my parishioners, hoping that I could gently guide them away from their rage. As I got older I continued to be diplomatic because I didn’t want to endanger my ministerial pension.

Finally, now that I’m past the midpoint of my lifespan, I’m speaking up.  In my last post, I tried to be kind but I guess I can’t expect people to take it well when I say they’re wrong. Some did, but others weren’t able to stay civil. It’s okay, I’m not scared of their rage anymore.

I am however, more resolved. And I’m putting people on notice that I’m standing up and speaking out.

*Pat Green is the author of   Transparent Expedition, a blog about being the parent of a transgender child.