Atheism Versus the Easter Bunny

Referring to a prominent atheist, the Christian comedian would say,

“Hey, I don’t believe in the Easter Bunny but I don’t make a career out of it.”

The Baptist performer made his career traveling the world using his funny stories as a tool for evangelism.  He was, and still is quite effective, with his blend of humor and pathos and I used to think his line about the Easter Bunny was funny.  

But let’s turn this around a bit and say, hypothetically, that instead of God, the comedian believed in something silly, like… the Easter Bunny, and made his career out of that belief.  What if he performed all over the country basing his message on this belief? 

And what if, when challenged, he took on a serene, sanctimonious look as he gave his witness: 

“I know it’s true,” he might say, “because I feel the Easter Bunny in my heart.  My parents taught me it was true and I still get a warm feeling when I sing the sweet childhood songs that proclaim the power of the Bunny.  I meet regularly with others to have special Bunny Study Groups and we encourage each other when our doubts haunt us.  Plus, once when I was hunting Easter eggs I had almost given up hope but then the Spirit of the Bunny spoke to my heart and showed me where I could find some—and I did! More than my basket could hold! So don’t tell me the Bunny isn’t real!” 

What if billions of people said the same thing? 

In that context, I think I could understand how someone might choose to make a career arguing against the existence of the Easter Bunny.   

Sure, it’s a silly scenario.  However, billions of people actually do profess a belief in a deity they have never seen, heard, or smelled, and they use the same, uh, reasoning to justify their belief.  And so, yes, some of us resist the concept although we rarely make a living from doing so.

Someone might ask me, “Why make things so unpleasant by arguing? Why not go on with your life and let people believe as they do?  Why can’t we all have mutual respect for each other?” 

Mutual respect sounds pretty good to me, and it would be a great starting place.  We could all be quiet and let everyone have their own thoughts.

So how about this:

I’ll get quiet when the Evangelical Christians do.  When they stop their global campaign, I’ll stop writing and talking.  I’ll stop speaking up when they stop trying to condition the minds of little children with songs, stories, and threats.  When they quit trying to force the schools and the government to carry their message for them, I’ll stop protesting.

Many Christians accuse atheists of having a hidden agenda, which I think takes a special blend of nerve and insanity, considering that their highest priority is to convert the entire world.

By the way, there’s nothing secret about the atheist agenda.  Simply stated, we won’t be forced to believe in God.

It may not be much of a career but it’s a powerful cause.  

A Challenge to My Christian Friends

Tell about your theology using critical reasoning.  How do you know that what you believe is true? 

Everybody in seminary has to do this. It’s an exercise to separate fact from feeling and truth from bias.  Many are quite shaken by the assignment.

Which reminds me… before you read further, let me say two things. First, if you’re in a vulnerable state, such as grief or illness, just skip over this post. Second, if you read further and it’s too disturbing, please understand that you can walk away from your computer screen and go right back to the security of your faith. I’ll understand.

I’m asking you to show me that your God is real.  Don’t tell me to go read a book or watch a movie or listen to your special preacher.  1 Peter 3:15 says to always be ready to give an account of your hope to someone who asks. So here I am, asking. 

Ready? Let’s begin.   

Can you describe God without using imagery? 

A clever story isn’t going to get the job done.  I’ve heard a lot of them and at one time I told them from the pulpit.  Metaphors, analogies, illustrations, and other literary devices can be valuable in their descriptive powers but they don’t prove anything. 

I’m aware that this takes out your best stuff: All those great preacher stories. And the biblical images: God is love. God is light. He is Abba Father. God is a nursing mother,  the Lord is our Shepherd.  Don’t forget the more severe ones where God is a Judge or a defending warrior.  And then there’s all that stuff in Revelation.

It’s all quite dramatic but it’s not proof.  If your God is real, you shouldn’t have to rely on imagery to talk about him. 

On to the next question:  

Can your God be described without quoting the Bible?

I’m a skeptic, and you can understand that your telling me the Bible is the inspired Word of God because the Bible says so just isn’t going to cut it.  Besides, truth is truth and it can stand on its own without having to quote chapter and verse.  So tell me something true.  

And don’t tell me to just open my eyes, look up, and see…. That’s subjective stuff.  Pointing to a flower, or a rhinoceros, or the sky and telling me that God made it… that’s not proof.  Neither is it proof when events worked out favorably after you prayed–that’s still subjective.  

This is the point where most people get exasperated, throw up their hands and mutter something about casting their pearls before swine.  You’ll want to dismiss me by saying God will remain a mystery as long as I refuse to believe.  But I don’t refuse to believe. I always wanted to believe.  I’ve spent my life trying to believe.  

So don’t be ashamed of your gospel.  You want to stand up for Jesus, don’t you?  You want to win me over don’t you? Wouldn’t that be a feather in your cap?  

However, you should be fair.  I want the chance to persuade you, too, not because I want you to come over to my side and not because I’m trying to deliver you to the devil.  I aim to win you over to yourself where you can own your thoughts and make your choices.   

I want to engage in real conversation.  I’ll try very hard to be respectful. I know that many of us atheists can get cranky and perhaps you can understand where that comes from when you realize that many of them have been ridiculed, excluded, and attacked by the people they love. Some have lost everything—jobs, marriages, family, children…. But I promise I won’t be mean to you, and I’ll ask my atheist friends who comment here to do the same.  

So talk to me in the comment section. Or you can email me, if you like, at damercer1961@gmail.com.  

Still Here and Still Me

I saw people at my mother’s funeral that I hadn’t seen in forty years.  The last time we were together, I had pimples and I was thin with thick dark hair.    

I have since evolved.

Now I’m thick with thinning gray hair, and the pimples are gone but the liver spots are blooming. 

 

But I’m still here and I’m still me. I’m still humorous, musical, creative, passionate, loving, and enormously graceful on the dance floor (Remember I said I was still humorous?).     

And to those who have been a part of my life, you haven’t gone away either. You are still with me in my mind.  Our conversations, feelings, experiences… they’re still inside me. They are part of the mix that is my identity.  

My mother died and I’m sad about it.  But I share DNA with her. The memories, her words, laughter, tears, music, squabbles, and struggles… they stayed with me. I don’t have to wait for an unseen heaven to realize that she didn’t really leave me.

I’ve traveled a long way from where I spent most of my life, and I live more privately now. But my friends from childhood, churches, and other communities have stayed with me in my mind through all the big changes.  I’ve had lots of tears and confusion but as they fade, I observe that I still have great love. 

I’m still me and I’m still here.  But I’m still evolving too.

I Won’t Stay Quiet

David, you’re hurting the church.  Why can’t you just be quiet?

I’ve been told all my life to be quiet for the sake of the church. Sure, I can preach, teach, guide, and help. But don’t challenge anyone or ask questions or express doubts because it hurts the church and I’ll go to hell Plus I could lose my job.

How do my words hurt anyone? The church claims to be an instrument of truth. How do people find truth if they are not allowed to ask, seek, and knock? Is the institution really so fragile that it can’t handle my voicing my thoughts?

When I was a young preacher in the churches of Christ, they taught that instrumental music in worship was evil. I thought it was ridiculous but I had to be careful with my words or I could lose my job. Later, I learned to refrain from voicing a dissenting opinion on baptism in the United Methodist church because I wanted to keep my job. For the same reason, I also kept quiet about much bigger issues, including our relationship with the LGBTQIA.

Yet job security was rarely mentioned. Instead, we spoke of how damaged the church could be if we even brought up these subjects. It’s interesting that an institution with the power to affect my life so dramatically could be so fragile.

Now, I’m still being urged to stay quiet. But I’m not going to. Silence makes us sick. It can even kill. I always wanted to be a healer so I’ll continue to speak up.

I’ll try to be respectful and reasonable. Just not quiet.