Bullies and Victims: When Will Smith Slapped Chris Rock

I’m trying to understand why so many of us were triggered by the slapping incident at the Oscars.  Some understood and even sympathized with Will Smith. Some were enraged that Chris Rock suffered from a slap in the face for simply doing his job. Others were offended, thinking Will took away his wife’s power to defend herself.   

Why so much angst over this particular incident? It was at a ceremony where members of the movie industry once again dressed up and congratulated themselves. Take away the silly pomp, and this moment boils down to a smart-aleck insulting a woman and getting slapped for it by her husband. It’s not really a big news item.  It might only have gotten a line in the public records somewhere, but it got more attention because it was on TV and occurred between artificially famous people.   

I can’t deny that it touched off some old trauma in me, which explains why my heart pounded, my fists clenched, and my eyes welled up every time I thought about it.  On the one hand, I think it’s wrong to hit people.  On the other hand, it’s wrong to insult people and then play the victim when someone retaliates.

I read an article by Melissa Hankins, MD, that referenced Will’s autobiography, where he describes how at the age of nine, he saw his mom get beaten by his father and then speaks of his lifelong regret that he didn’t have the courage to defend her.  Hankins suggests that this childhood trauma is behind Will’s actions at the Oscars. It doesn’t excuse Will’s actions, but perhaps it helps explain them.[i]

I think Chris Rock was violent, too.  I know he is a professional comedian expected to ridicule people, and for some reason, society says that’s okay. But he used his position to say something hurtful, which is also a form of violence.

I maintain that words can be used as a form of violence. Children can suffer lifelong damage from their parents’ words. Spouses can traumatize each other with them.  Some preachers hurt their congregations with rage-filled words couched behind religiosity.  And crowds are stirred to physical violence with words.   

I grew up watching people I love being harmed by the spoken word. I have spent my entire adult life feeling guilt over childhood memories where I thought I should have stood up for someone even though I was just a child myself.  I’m sure I became a professional caregiver to protect and help people heal from their long-term wounds. 

People can say Will Smith is a bully, but I understand that he thought he was standing up to a bully. Others can speculate that his wife manipulated him, but to whom else would she show her tears? And some of us can say Chris Rock is a bully, too, but maybe he is also a victim of childhood abuse. In fact, I’d bet money that he was.

The older I get, the more I see only the wounds of others, which don’t excuse wrong actions, but perhaps they are a key to real healing for people.


[i] https://www.kevinmd.com/2022/03/will-smiths-slap-is-a-trauma-response.html?fbclid=IwAR1YaO8OKeDLob0z2auyir6pUQ3didYfrWW0BWYnp47uh9JCw3sr__6YoDw

Performing a Wiccan Wedding: A Change in Perspective

I stopped in a church parking lot and got off the motorcycle to stretch my legs and get my bearings. A car pulled up beside me and the passenger window rolled down. The older gentleman at the wheel leaned over to speak to me.

“I’m the pastor of this church,” he said. Can I help you with anything?”

“No thanks,” I said. “I’m just taking a break.”

“I’m a retired minister, myself,” I continued. “I’m on my way to perform a wedding ceremony.”

He brightened when he realized he was talking to a colleague. We chatted and traded pedigrees.  He was a preacher for an Independent Fundamentalist Baptist Church–very conservative.  I told him where I was educated and confessed I was on the liberal end of the spectrum, although I chose not to reveal that I was now an atheist humanist celebrant. We were cordial and wished each other well as I glided away on the bike.

I also neglected to tell him I would be performing my first Wiccan wedding.

I reached the park and met with the wedding party and their families.  They were a little stressed as most wedding participants are, but they were also pleasant and kind. The young man was tall, slender, and perhaps shy. I helped him straighten his tie and I took the opportunity to clasp his shoulders and say he was a handsome young man. The beautiful young woman had long hair and wore a simple but elegant dress. The party also included a small adorable baby girl. 

It was my first Wiccan ceremony, and although I once taught World Religions in college, I had to study up on the proceedings.  We conducted the ceremony by a luminescent spring.

Green Springs Park, by David Mercer
Green Springs Park, by David Mercer

The woman laid out a circle of small rocks around us.  The father of the bride handed the young man a small knife (called an athame) as a symbolic act of passing the responsibility of protecting his daughter to the man who would be her husband. In the handfasting ritual, I wrapped a thin rope loosely around the bride and groom’s wrists. When they pulled their hands away, they held onto the ends of the rope, forming a knot in the middle. Near the end, they jumped over a broom to signify stepping into a new life.

While the baby gurgled, they offered each other their vows using words like love, community, life forces, eternity, magic, the sun, moon, land, and sea. At the end, I pronounced them married and they kissed each other.

The preacher I met earlier would be obligated to believe these proceedings were evil, which is preposterous. They are a lovely couple, joining hands to make their way in life. They value the qualities of wonder, love, and each other. They embrace the idea of making the world a better place. And they are kind and gracious.

When I was a young conservative preacher, I often said Wiccan was evil, which I see now is preposterous. I regret that I might have caused someone to feel pain from my words. I’m glad I’m in a different place where I get to participate in the formalized union of this sweet little family.

Green Springs Park by David Mercer

It Was Nice to Meet You

We made our way through the hallways of the nursing home, entered a small room, and approached the hospital bed. 

“Mama,” my aunt said, “David is here. He came to see you.”

“Hi David,” she said.

“Hi, Nana. How do you feel?”

“Just fine.” 

She was ninety-three and had endured many bouts with death, but now her time was near.

She was a small feisty woman, sometimes clairvoyant, and always full of love, humor, nurture, and music. She had always been poor, yet she was generous. Affection flowed easily from her that could heal people, plants, and animals. 

She was motionless, too tired to open her eyes, and her voice was weak. Dementia had set in; however, although she couldn’t remember where she was or who standing at her bedside, her affection still showed.    

“Nana,” I brought my two children so they could meet you.”

I held them up one at a time. They were small, shy, and wordless, and she couldn’t see them anyway with her eyes closed. 

“This is Jonathan.”

“Hi Jonathan,” she said. 

“This is Joshua.”

“Hi Joshua,” she said.

“We won’t stay long, but I wanted to see you and tell you I love you.”

“I love you, too.”

I don’t know how long we stood there. I wanted to tell her over and over that I loved her. I wanted to say I was sorry for not having seen her enough. I wanted her to know my children. And I wanted to thank her….

“We should go now,” I said. “You need your rest. Bye, Nana.”

“Bye-bye,” she said, “It was nice to meet you.”

Was she addressing my children, or did she forget who we were, trying to bluff her way through the end of the conversation?

It was the last thing she said to me.

It was nice to meet you. What did that mean?

When I think of my relationships, it feels like our encounters are very brief, no matter how long we’ve known each other. We meet for a moment and then we move on. Friends move in and out of our lives, children grow up fast, and loved ones die too soon… always too soon. 

“Wait… I’m not ready for you to go,” I want to say.

I try to hold onto the moment and make it count. But I can’t slow it down, and I’m always surprised when it’s gone. Grief piles up over the years and weighs me down. Is there a way to be grateful and happy to have had the moments and then move on without such crippling sadness?

Nana survived many hard things. She had nothing, including her memories when she died. And yet she loved until the end. Maybe that’s the secret.

And maybe another secret is accepting that life is full of fleeting moments, and even if we share many of them with someone we love, it’s still brief. In which case, it was good to meet them. 

Rocky Mountain Shame

John Denver’s song, “Rocky Mountain High,” was popular when I was ten years old. At school, our teacher played it every day, giving us the written words to sing along with it. 

I loved it. I could feel the elation and wonder the song describes. My favorite line was, “I know he’d be a poorer man if he never saw an eagle fly.” I lived in the hot, dusty plains, but I could imagine walking in the cool mountains, and watching a bald eagle soar and dive.

Hochatown Nature Photography by Randy Sander, Facebook page

However, I stopped listening to “Rocky Mountain High” because I was afraid it would lead me away from my religion.

Another line in the song said, “He could talk to God and listen to the casual reply.” I told myself that this line should be my favorite, not the one about the eagle. But I couldn’t keep myself from loving the eagle that flew in John Denver’s music. So I avoided the song to avoid the conflict.

There’s a component of this that’s worth identifying: having any strong positive feeling created inner conflict for me.   

We were taught to distrust intense feelings in our home, and we often warned each other not to get too happy. Any member of the family who became excited at good news would quickly become an object of scorn. We scorned people outside of the family for the same thing. In fact, John Denver was often disdained in our house because we deemed him undeserving of his success, but I think it was really because his music stirred people, which made us uncomfortable. 

I think this was part of a larger dysfunction of our religion. In our church, we were suspicious of anything too emotional. We thought it was dangerous to get too caught up in wonder or elation because happiness couldn’t possibly be spiritual. So we stayed as serious as possible and clamped down on the young ones if they got too enthusiastic.    

I’m not sure where this aversion to joy comes from, but I think it’s connected to things like jealousy, depression, fear, and a lot of shame.   

It’s hard to find an individual to blame when looking at how culture affects us. The older people who raised us were products of their culture, too, and it takes a few generations to recognize and weed out the harmful characteristics. 

As for me, I think I’ll listen to some of John Denver’s music. Maybe I’ll have an inner conversation about allowing myself to be happy. Perhaps I’ll even make an effort to forgive and heal myself some. 

Throwing Away the Script

“I need to get to church this Sunday,” my new friend said. “I’ve missed it lately and I need to get back. My whole week goes so much better when I go to church.” 

She’s a little older than me. Sweet… funny… kind.  As we chatted,  I nodded to show I was listening to her. 

Then she asked me: “Do you go to church?”

My head changed from going up and down to back and forth.

“Why not?” she asked, surprised

I gave a smile and a shrug.

She gave me her disapproving look. “You need to go,” she said.

I continued to smile and not answer.

“WHY don’t you go to church?” she said.

Not long ago, I would have told her I was an atheist, that I used to go to church, and in fact, I was a preacher, but now I have had enough of religion. Instead, I said gently.  “I don’t want to.” which prompted her to sputter.     

Bible Belters follow a script for moments like this but I was opting out of it.    

I could have said:

“I’ve been meaning to get back to church.”

She would have considered it an acceptable response but it ran the risk of prompting her to invite me to her church. Then I would have had to lie and say, “Thanks, I’ll try to make it sometime.” I’d never have any intention of doing so but she would feel better for having made an effort.   

But, like I said, I didn’t feel like following the script.

 “Didn’t you go when you were a kid?” she pressed.

“Yes. My dad was a preacher,” I volunteered.  “In fact, he still is.”

“He IS?” 

This time I gave a head nod. She went back to the script. 

“You should go back,” she said with a parental glare. I’m going to call your daddy and tell him that you’re not going.”

“You’re going to tell on me?” I laughed.  

She laughed too.  “Well I ought to,” she said. 

Then she went off the usual script, but it was still within the context of the show.

“I’m ashamed of you.” She said

“What?”

She repeated it and waited for my response. Most people aren’t so forthright. They let that part hang silently over the conversation like a dark cloud.

At this point, I suppose I could have taken the conversation in varying directions.  

Perhaps I could have shown a little remorse.

“You’re right,” I could have said. “I need to get my act together”.

Or I could have shown some outrage. “Who do you think you are?”

Or maybe I could have tried to explain myself.  “I’m sorry but I don’t believe anymore.”  But then I would have had to defend my not believing, and I’m tired of that.

I chose another direction and used my West Texas drawl.

“Oh now…, don’t talk that way…. You’re gonna hurt my feelings.”

I let her see my eyes twinkle.  She laughed and we went on to other topics

Why didn’t I get mad at her?

Because in the deepest part of herself, she didn’t mean it. She was trying to do what her religious leaders taught her to do and I could see that it caused her pain to say it.  But she thought she was supposed to.

She was the real victim, being forced to say things that weren’t part of her gentle nature. 

 I could have gone to my script and lectured her on the evils of religion, the superiority of science, and maybe thrown in some thoughts about the separation between church and state.

But… no.

A verse in her Bible says that a soft word turns away wrath (Proverbs 15:1). Maybe it can turn away religious aggression, too. In any case, she’s still my friend who knows that I have a different perspective. Perhaps when she’s ready we can have another conversation. 

Family Gathering

Sylvia and I stopped for a late breakfast at Denny’s before going to an afternoon play. 

Across the dining room, we watched a family having their meal: a mom, a little boy, and four nearly grown sons, with the papa at the head of the table. They were having a great time eating, laughing, and sharing affection.

“Like a Norman Rockwell painting,” Sylvia observed.

I remembered growing up in a large family where there was often mirth at mealtime, with my dad as the ringleader. This dad saw me staring at his family so I smiled and nodded to him, and he returned it.

Something about them pulled at me.

“I wish had the money to buy their breakfast,” I said impulsively.

“I’ve got some,” Sylvia said, “You want to?”

Yes, I did. 

I found their waitress and asked for their ticket. 

“Um, sure,” she said. She printed it up and handed it to me. Then she went to the dad to tell him that their breakfast was paid for and pointed me out.

He turned to look at me, and I gave him a quick two-finger salute. I went over to meet him. I told him that it made us feel good to watch them and we wanted to do this for them. He accepted our gift with a gracious thanks, a handshake, and finally a hug.

“Thanks, babe,” I said when I got back to the table. She’d been watching from her seat.

“Life with you is fun,” she said.

We went on to see the play. As usual, the Shakes Theater did a wonderful job.  The title of the play was “Sweet Water Taste,” written by Gloria Bond Clunie, and it addressed racial conflict with humor, courage, and sympathy. 

It was about two ornery old men: one black, one white, who found out that they were related to each other. The black man visited the white man’s house to demand he and his family be buried in the private family cemetery where only white folks had been laid to rest.

In the beginning, the white man appeared to be a gracious southern gentleman. But then he was presented with this request, and he became a blustering fool.

“The family is not ready,” he protested.  “You’re asking too much too soon.”

“It has been 300 years and you’re still not ready!” said the black man. He spoke of working hard to earn his fortune and struggling all his life to be recognized as a man.  He decided this was going to be his last fight.

The play was well written and brought out the hidden prejudices and resentment we still struggle to recognize and reconcile. I saw a great deal of my own racist culture in the old white man.

I’ve heard his protestations all my life: He’d supported black people when he could. And he’d always been a friend to “the coloreds.” But he’d be damned if he would allow a n—-r to be buried in his cemetery no matter how much evidence proved they were related, and no matter what the courts might rule.

The play shows how we have much further to go in the healing between cultures.

As we drove home, I thought again about the family at Denny’s. I had asked them if they were in town for vacation.

“We came for football camp for my sons,” he said.

“They’re certainly big enough to play football,” I smiled.

“Unfortunately, they didn’t get to go,” The father said. “I was arrested when we got into town because I was profiled for a crime that had just happened.”

Oh yeah… did I mention this was an African American family? 

“Are you ok?” I asked.

“Oh, I’m fine,” he said, “I’m doing what I can to salvage the weekend and show the family a good time. Thanks again for your gift.”

When it was time to leave, he had his five sons file past the table where Sylvia and I sat and they each thanked us. The youngest son shook my hand.

The mom came last.

“So… all boys,” I said. “How do you manage that?”

“I can’t even begin….” She said and shrugged without finishing the sentence. 

She walked past, then turned and said, “But they make me feel safe.”

It’s her that I think about now. I’m glad she has her handsome sons to protect her.  But how would it feel to worry about them and their father every damn time they walked out the door?   

We still have so much further to go.

A Child’s Power

The tired parents were struggling to work the machine at the self-checkout and had tuned out their toddler who was sitting in the grocery cart. He was bursting to help them work the machine. He stood up in his precarious perch so he could see better and he hollered at them to let him help.  Then he leaned and stretched to try to touch the machine but he was too far away, and he started to teeter. I was sure he was going to fall to the floor. 

I stepped over, reached out, and held the little boy, helping him gain his footing.  His parents turned and saw what nearly happened. And like tired parents do, they scolded him, while he ignored them.  He was still trying to get at the self-checkout machine. 

It has been a long time since I’ve held a child. In that brief contact, I felt that little boy’s energy and a wave flooded over me of memories where I held my own children when they were small. I’d forgotten how powerful the vitality of a small child can be.

Photo by Bess Hamiti on Pexels.com

What do I want to say here…?

I want to say that I miss holding my children.

Sometimes I missed seeing who they really were.

I also want to say that the story of a child born in utter poverty, who grows up to be the savior of humanity still resonates with me even though I’m an atheist.

Somebody’s children will one day find the cure for cancer. And somebody’s children will be significant ambassadors for peace.  And somebody’s children will be teachers, artists, scientists, and healers. And some will be almost anonymous workers who make life possible for their communities.

I think all children have the potential for greatness that can change the world. Sometimes I can almost see that greatness sparkling just beneath the surface of a child. 

I held one of those children briefly at the self checkout.

The Good and Faithful Servant

It had already been night for several hours.  After a long day, we had our normal rush of customers just as we were closing the store. A coworker who had been standing at the register for several hours became sick and began to sink to the floor. But a customer saw she was in distress and moved quickly to catch her. 

He eased her to the ground, held her head in his lap, and asked for someone to call an ambulance. Then he spoke quietly to soothe the woman until help arrived. 

We moved the remaining customers to other registers so the ambulance attendants could do their work.  An older man came through my line and said to me, “The same thing happened to my wife earlier this year.  She fell when she had a stroke and died right then.”

At that point, we were relieved to see my coworker revive a bit.   

I turned back to the older gentleman.  “I’m so sorry you lost your wife, sir.”  I wondered if he might be emotionally triggered so I asked if he was okay.

“I’m fine,” he said, and then he pointed to the man holding my friend. “That’s my son.”

A million things went through me. I was worried about my coworker and also feeling this man’s grief as he remembered his loss. And that man who was taking care of my friend…. Was he also feeling the grief of losing his mother? Did he get a chance to hold his mother when she was ill? Or was this a chance to do what he wished he could have done for his mother?  While my mind churned, I moved quickly to check out our final customers.  

The ambulance came and took her to the hospital and the man who had held her came to my register to join his father.

“I think she’s going to be okay,” he said. (In fact, I have heard that she is feeling better now).

“Thank you for helping my friend, sir,” I said. “Well done.”  

“It was God that helped me,” he said. 

I nodded.   

 “Perhaps I should say, ‘Well done, good and faithful servant.’”

He smiled and blinked to hold back the tears in his eyes. 

I Counted In Church

Leaving the church was one of the hardest things I’ve ever done.  I have no qualms about letting go of God and religion.  But the people–I loved them and I still do.    

I am aware of the flaws, dysfunction, and outright abuse that happened in many churches, and I understand that those who were harmed must speak up.  But I think I was protected from a lot of that because my father was the pastor and he was protective of his churches. 

When I was thirteen, I talked him into giving me a key to the church building and I would be the first one to arrive and the last one to leave. I didn’t want to miss a minute.   The church was pretty wonderful to me as I was growing up.  While I was a clumsy, lonely kid in school, the church treated me like I was special.  I had friends of all ages who were glad to see me.  They hugged me, helped me, and applauded me.   

When I was very little, I sat with Mrs. Luker during the worship service. She gave me gum just for coming to be with her. We used to race each other to see who could find the songs in the hymnal first.  I remember cracking the code of counting… you know when you reach number 9 and move over to the next column and start over…?  I was unstoppable when I picked up on that secret and then I beat her every time.

When I was five years old, our Sunday school teacher had us stand up and speak into the microphone at the podium. It was a clunky, old-fashioned instrument.  I liked how it felt in my hand as I adjusted it back and forth.  When I spoke into it, my voice boomed throughout the auditorium, sounding just like my dad.  Years later, the teacher told me that she had to literally pull me from that microphone.

I learned about music in church. We didn’t use pianos and organs but we were all encouraged to sing.  I remember when I first recognized the different harmonies going on in our congregation. I would lean my head back and pick out the different parts. I heard my mom’s alto underneath the melody, and I especially enjoyed hearing the men sing bass.

When I got a little older, I learned to perform by joining the puppet ministry. I was this soft-spoken kid who became an outrageous ham when I hid behind the curtain and spoke with a puppet.

To sum up, I found music and my voice in church because I counted. 

I’m sorry I couldn’t stay.

I No Longer Reach for Heaven

In the churches of Christ, our religion was never really about heaven. Oh, we talked about it all the time, but really, it was unattainable. Instead, we lived under the self imposed threat of hell and condemnation.

We had a long list of things that snatched heaven away from our grasp: 

First, if you weren’t a true member of the Church of Christ, you couldn’t go to heaven. Baptists were condemned. So were the Methodists, Catholics, Pentecostals, and then all those other heathen religions on the other side of the world.

The Bible was the Word of God to be taken literally and if you didn’t believe in it the way we believed in it, you were going to hell. 

The only valid baptism was to be dunked completely in water and only then were you saved–until you had an impure thought, which is a sin as bad as murder, and made you condemned again.

Instrumental music in worship would send you to hell.

You couldn’t drink, dance, or let boys and girls swim together.

And no looking at women with lust in our hearts. That one pretty much sunk me. 

I knew I wasn’t going to make it to heaven although I kept trying year after year, along with my fellow church members, but it was pretty hopeless.  However, we each kept our doubts to ourselves because we were supposed to be positive that we were going to heaven, which added another layer of craziness to the mix. 

We went out into the world sharing this message of “Good News.” I’m astounded that anyone could be persuaded to accept a way of life that guarantees their condemnation.  But I’m sorry to say we made converts. It makes me think of Jesus words:

You shut the door of the kingdom of heaven in people’s faces. You yourselves do not enter, nor will you let those enter who are trying to…. You travel over land and sea to win a single convert, and when you have succeeded, you make them twice as much a child of hell as you are.

–Matthew 23:13-15 NIV

When I got to college, I stumbled into teachings that said although we were all sinners, Jesus’ sacrifice made it possible to be forgiven and allowed into heaven.  I remember the relief flooding through me when I realized I’d been let off the hook and was delivered from the fear of spending eternity in a place seven times hotter than the sun.

That was the message I preached to my churches.  I vowed to be a minister that made heaven available to everyone. I told the stories of Jesus touching lepers and saving prostitutes. I chose scriptures that emphasized the concepts of grace, forgiveness, and redemption.  Sometimes I was criticized for talking too much about grace and not enough about condemnation, which made me proud because I was proclaiming truth in the face of persecution–if people being snotty to me could be called persecution. 

It took an incredibly long time for me to see the flaw of a god circumventing his own wrath through a human sacrifice in order to offer his kindness to humanity.  Eventually, I decided hell just didn’t fit in a context of God loving everyone unconditionally.  Finally, I rejected the whole idea of deity and religion.  

I guess I’ve come full circle. I’m still not going to heaven but I’m no longer afraid.