Chicken in Church (and It’s Not Potluck)

I also offered last week’s posting to a Facebook page for conservative Christians.  To repeat, I was posing the challenge: “Can you describe God without using scripture or imagery?” As with progressive Christians, I received some thoughtful responses but they were almost drowned out by a few angry individuals.

I grew up with Christian conservatives and I was one of them for a long time. I’m still friends with a number of conservative ministers, and while we disagree these days, they’re good folk.

But not these guys. I think they use conservative Christianity as cover for their domineering tendencies.   

My goodness, they were energetic. They criticized, ridiculed, and occasionally threatened me with hellfire. Instead of answering what should have been a basic question for them, they tried to change the conversation, countering with their own challenges.    

“You atheists are so arrogant.  How do YOU think the world was made? Huh? Are YOU smarter than GOD? Do you know more than THE BIBLE? You’re nothing but a HYPOCRITE!  And you’re so ANGRY!”    

I tangled with them more than I meant to, and of course it was a waste of time. However, here is my final response:  

Bwak bwak bwak bwaaak….

I call “chicken.”

They blustered and bloviated because they didn’t have an answer.  And that’s just chicken.

Honestly, if I was still a believing conservative minister, I’d have been embarrassed at how poorly they responded. 

But more than embarrassed, I’m outraged at their bullying behavior. I’m immune to their tactics but not everyone is.  I’ve seen how people like them treat the vulnerable. I’ve seen how they rail at their own congregations. I’ve seen them intimidate the children into believing.  

When I was a pastor, I often comforted those who had been savaged by “ministers” like them. It made me mad then and it makes me mad now.

I see they’re still out there using religion to dominate people.  

I’m still here too. 

And not only do I say they’re chicken. I’m calling foul. 

I Won’t Stay Quiet

David, you’re hurting the church.  Why can’t you just be quiet?

I’ve been told all my life to be quiet for the sake of the church. Sure, I can preach, teach, guide, and help. But don’t challenge anyone or ask questions or express doubts because it hurts the church and I’ll go to hell Plus I could lose my job.

How do my words hurt anyone? The church claims to be an instrument of truth. How do people find truth if they are not allowed to ask, seek, and knock? Is the institution really so fragile that it can’t handle my voicing my thoughts?

When I was a young preacher in the churches of Christ, they taught that instrumental music in worship was evil. I thought it was ridiculous but I had to be careful with my words or I could lose my job. Later, I learned to refrain from voicing a dissenting opinion on baptism in the United Methodist church because I wanted to keep my job. For the same reason, I also kept quiet about much bigger issues, including our relationship with the LGBTQIA.

Yet job security was rarely mentioned. Instead, we spoke of how damaged the church could be if we even brought up these subjects. It’s interesting that an institution with the power to affect my life so dramatically could be so fragile.

Now, I’m still being urged to stay quiet. But I’m not going to. Silence makes us sick. It can even kill. I always wanted to be a healer so I’ll continue to speak up.

I’ll try to be respectful and reasonable. Just not quiet.

Hell: NO!

Tis the season for Halloween.  Many churches object to the holiday, calling it satanic, yet at the same time, some of those churches will offer alternatives that are truly satanic. Their haunted houses (often called, “Hell House”) offer images of hell complete with fire, demons, and torture. You know, fun for the whole family. 

Did you know the word for hell is not in the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) at all? It’s only mentioned once in the New Testament (2 Peter 2:4).  A few other verses speak of something we assume refers to hell but there’s a lot of room for discussion about it. 

Our concept of hell comes from Dante or perhaps Milton and we’ve added to it over the centuries.  We’ve certainly used it to frighten and control people, especially the children, and that troubles me greatly. Fear of hell was always a rotten motivator, however it can stoke the general anxiety of people.  

I always soft pedaled the eternal punishment part of my preaching even in my early period when I was a conservative fundamentalist.  A few years back I quit believing the church’s teaching on it because it just didn’t hold up theologically.  In my final years, I did not speak of it at all from the pulpit and I quietly told individuals that my thoughts had changed on the subject.

I observe that hell has lost a lot of its fire these days.  It doesn’t appear to scare us so much anymore, which suits me fine. 

Why Aren’t We the Innovators?

Jesus replied, “Very truly I tell you, no one can see the kingdom of God unless they are born again.”

“How can someone be born when they are old?” Nicodemus asked. “Surely they cannot enter a second time into their mother’s womb to be born!”

“You are Israel’s teacher,” said Jesus, “and do you not understand these things?”

–John 3:3-4, 10 (NIV).

————————————————–

We followed mirages,

And fought over their reality.

I tried to help carry others

But now I don’t.

I stumble forward by myself…

—————————————————-

We brought in an enthusiastic speaker to get us revved up. He spoke our old beliefs as if they were brand new. He was funny, positive, and spoke in a rhythmic cadence that invited us to shout our hallelujahs and amens.

“Turn to your neighbor and say, ‘Jesus is ALIVE!’” And everyone did but me.

Later, a friend asked me “What did you think of it?”

“I think everything we said tonight was exactly the same as what we said in the 1970s, only we’re all grayer and slower.”

“Maybe we need to be reminded to go back to our old ways,” my friend suggested.

Maybe our old ways led to our decline,” I countered.

Jesus once said that we must be born again. He didn’t mean that we needed to return to infantile ways or to go back to do it all again the same way. I think he was saying to let go of the old ways and become something that we have never been before. We need to reach higher planes of awareness by thinking new thoughts and dreaming new dreams.

But we’re not doing that. We never have. The church has always expended most of its energy in staying exactly the same, keeping the same beliefs intact, and repeating the same activities. In fact, people will fight hard against newness and they hurt those who challenge the church effectively.

Why?

Why isn’t the church a champion for creativity, experimentation, and innovation? Why didn’t we celebrate Copernicus and Galileo? Why aren’t we more curious about scientific discovery? Why aren’t we leading the way in social change?

I don’t know. And to tell the truth, I’m losing interest in analyzing why we’ve failed. I’m only interested in moving forward, even if it’s by myself.

The apostle Paul once said that we were baptized to walk in newness of life. But we are scared to do it. It’s much easier to march toward death while insisting we are right.

Angry Outcasts

I want to talk about those people who didn’t just fade away from church. They walked out and slammed the door, stating they will never enter a church building again.

They once participated wholeheartedly in their churches. They were bathed in church customs, learned the doctrines, memorized biblical passages, and took notes with pens of different colors during the sermon.  They went to Sunday school, prayer meetings, Vacation Bible School, and church camp. They evangelized their friends and went on mission outreaches. They tithed. They came early and stayed late, often doing menial chores in the church building. They weren’t just faithful members… they were the best members.

But…

At some point they began to be plagued by nagging doubts and questions:

“If God loves the world so much why does he allow…?”

Or…

“If God is so powerful, why doesn’t he…?

Or…

“How can the pastor and my teachers be so certain that they are right?”

And…

“What if none of this is true?”

When they gave voice to these unwelcome thoughts, their friends, family, and pastors shushed them, warning them to guard their minds against such things.  When they persevered with their questions, loved ones reacted with even more pressure, warning them not to let the Devil seduce them lest they fall from the kingdom of God.

Finally, they could no longer tolerate the force-feeding. They summoned every ounce of courage they had to say aloud that they just didn’t believe anymore.  As a result, they lost everything: family, community, often their jobs. The people they once depended on for love and acceptance now despised and rejected them.

Is it any wonder they’re angry? From their perspective, they’ve been lied to all their lives.  They’re not just angry–they are enraged because they feel like they were brainwashed.  They look around and see that much of the world still believes the things they once believed and they want to scream, “NO, THIS IS NOT TRUE!

Yet as furious as they are, they’re also lonely and displaced, and they miss that sense of belonging they once had. They hear the siren’s song of the hymn: “come home… come home….” But most of them can’t. They won’t ever again relinquish the right to think for themselves.

I have many things to say about this subject. But I want to end this post by saying something that I wish I’d been saying from the pulpit for the last thirty-five years:

Parents, your children are more important than your religion.

As they become grown, you have to respect their right to believe (or not believe) as they wish. You want them to visit you? You want to see your grandchildren? Then stop trying to force them back into your religion.

I know, I know. You don’t want to lose them to hell.  But you could lose them right now if you don’t back off.  Religion is about faith. So how about showing some faith in the people you love that they’ll find their own way? They might even turn out to know more than you.

It’s Time to Use the Bible Competently

Recently, because of my statements about the church and the LGBT, I’ve often been asked if I believe or care what the Bible actually says.  Those discussions led me to write the following:

Here’s some basic Bible information which is known by all mainline biblical scholars.  If your preacher went to seminary, even an ultra conservative one, they should at least be aware of this information.

The Pentateuch has three, maybe four authors and none of them are Moses. There are two creation stories, although John’s version would make it three.  There are two versions of the flood story and two (maybe three) versions of the ten commandments. There are also two accounts of the early kingdoms of Israel with references to other books of record that no longer exist.  There are four gospels. Scholars speculate there was a fifth one that was written earlier.  Each gospel differs in part from the others, sometimes markedly so.  Additionally, there are discrepancies between the events recorded in Acts and the writings of Paul.

The differences are real but they do not invalidate the scriptures unless we insist that they are completely consistent historically, scientifically, and theologically.

The Bible is a collection of books written over hundreds of years. It is a compilation of various theological viewpoints.  For instance, Proverbs often states a promise that God protects and rewards the righteous person.  But the book of Job refutes this viewpoint by telling the story of a man who did everything right, yet nevertheless, God allowed him to suffer terribly. Then the writer of Ecclesiastes says, “What’s the use? It’s all hopeless. Focus on your day’s work and do what God says.” Put all that together and you’re going to have lots of ideas to exchange, and it makes for fascinating discussion designed to make us think and search ourselves.

It’s way past time to set aside the notion that the Bible is a book of definitive rules and laws. It never was. Within the pages there are records of laws that people had for themselves but they weren’t designed to be binding on all cultures for all time.

I’m sorry to break it to you but we have to take more responsibility in ascertaining truth by using our thoughts.  Often we can do this by consensus, particularly when it comes to establishing lawful societies. And when societies evolve, so do the laws. In fact they evolved even within the pages of scripture.

Some people insist that they actually follow the Bible literally but they don’t. They pick and choose the laws they prefer, weave them together into their doctrine, then put God’s name on it. That might be okay but they also inject their biases into their beliefs without even being aware. That’s understandable too, but if they assume that God actually endorses their biases and then attempt to bind people to them, well… then we have a problem.

This is how the rationale was developed that women could be regarded as less than human in earlier times. It’s astonishing how only in the last century they’ve been allowed to vote, borrow money, and have their own businesses.  Some churches still don’t give them a voice, much less ordination. All of this was/is justified by scripture, or I should say by people’s perception of scripture.

Some passages endorse slavery and they were used to justify the owning of persons in the United States until the nineteenth century.

I’m divorced. When I was a young minister divorced people were run out of churches, refused baptism, and prohibited from preaching.  In fact it still happens and the scriptures are used to justify it.

Now we come to the LGBT who continue to be treated as barely tolerated sinners. They are excluded from sanctioned weddings as well as ordination.  People within church walls, often from the pulpit, revile them, using their favorite scriptures.

Such use of the Bible is more than incompetent. It’s more than ignorant. It can be downright wicked.  We do not have license from God through scripture to deny people their dignity and rights.

Want to champion outstanding values, teach right morals, and have good laws? Please, by all means, take responsibility and make it happen.  Use your powers of persuasion.  But don’t expect to get a free pass by saying, “The Bible says so.”

To My Compassionate Conservative Friends

To my compassionate conservative friends in ministry:

In my last post, I confronted those who use religion to hurt others, specifically the LGBT. I know that’s not you because I was once one of you.  You are earnest teachers and you never stop searching for truth.  You visit the sick, lead your churches to feed the hungry, and spearhead mission efforts. If someone in front of you needs your help, you give it freely, no matter who they are.

You are true ministers.  You have an unstoppable drive to make things better, and you’d rather die than hurt anyone.

But you and I know there is a major element in our society who use religion to hurt and control others and often they use the conservative ideology to do it.  Ok, they’re on the other side of the spectrum, too, I guess, but in the South we usually find them hiding among the conservatives.  I know you hate what they do.  I know it embarrasses and frustrates you to spend so much time quietly keeping them in check so they won’t hurt your people. I know you don’t want people to think you’re one of them.

You have my sympathy and my support.

I think you wish I’d be quiet, but I can’t. I held my tongue for so long it made me sick.  So I’m going to speak my thoughts.  I’m going to say things that maybe you wish you could say but would cost you too much.

I’m going to say things you disagree with. I will argue as strenuously as I can and I won’t back off.  I don’t expect you to, either.  We’re all grownups–we can discuss our thoughts without degenerating into angry babies.

My friends, I love and respect you.  But I’m not where you are anymore. I don’t see the Bible the way you do. I don’t understand God as you do. I don’t like where our religion has taken us–I think it’s doing a lot of harm. I think the church should quit trying to go backward to the good old days and instead go forward to be something it has never known itself to be.

It should make for great discussion.

I’m also aiming at those who are spiritually violent, who wrap themselves in the pages of a Bible they never understood, yet nonetheless use to oppress the weak. They use some of the same language you do.

But I know the difference.