You Don’t Have to Forgive

In my last years of ministry, I quit preaching about forgiveness because it did more harm than good. 

When I did speak on the subject, I was aiming at the grudge-holding, petty sniping that went on where people used their resentment to keep others trapped in shame.  However those people never heard me except to use my words to inflict more wounds on their victims.   

Enough of that. 

With whatever remnants of pastoral authority I still have, I want to say this to the victims of violence and sexual assault:

You don’t have to forgive your abuser. 

I know, I know… the Bible says don’t let the sun go down on your anger.  But frankly, I think it would be better to go to bed mad rather than scared or hopeless.  Get out of harm’s way if you can. You’ve turned the cheek plenty of times.  It’s time to rescue yourself. By the way, asking for help is part of the rescue operation.   

I hope that there will be a day when the sun goes down and you can finally go to bed feeling… safe.

My friend, Dr. Christy Sim, is an expert on surviving and healing.  You can see her website at https://drchristysim.wordpress.com/.  If you’d like to support her work, go to https://www.patreon.com/DrChristySim

 

I Won’t Stay Quiet

David, you’re hurting the church.  Why can’t you just be quiet?

I’ve been told all my life to be quiet for the sake of the church. Sure, I can preach, teach, guide, and help. But don’t challenge anyone or ask questions or express doubts because it hurts the church and I’ll go to hell Plus I could lose my job.

How do my words hurt anyone? The church claims to be an instrument of truth. How do people find truth if they are not allowed to ask, seek, and knock? Is the institution really so fragile that it can’t handle my voicing my thoughts?

When I was a young preacher in the churches of Christ, they taught that instrumental music in worship was evil. I thought it was ridiculous but I had to be careful with my words or I could lose my job. Later, I learned to refrain from voicing a dissenting opinion on baptism in the United Methodist church because I wanted to keep my job. For the same reason, I also kept quiet about much bigger issues, including our relationship with the LGBTQIA.

Yet job security was rarely mentioned. Instead, we spoke of how damaged the church could be if we even brought up these subjects. It’s interesting that an institution with the power to affect my life so dramatically could be so fragile.

Now, I’m still being urged to stay quiet. But I’m not going to. Silence makes us sick. It can even kill. I always wanted to be a healer so I’ll continue to speak up.

I’ll try to be respectful and reasonable. Just not quiet.

What Do I Call Myself?

It’s hard to find the words to describe myself.

Am I a nonbeliever? An agnostic? A heretic?  An infidel?  These terms suggest that I have lost my identity and am reacting erratically  like a bouncing pinball. But I haven’t lost myself. I’m growing up.

 “What happened that made you lose your faith?” asked a friend. 

There was no one event.  Others like me have said it is like “dying from a thousand cuts,” meaning that it happened gradually.

I remember the first time I seriously questioned my belief nearly two decades ago. I was sick and unhappy, and I prayed hard for help.  I didn’t need much–just some kind of reassurance, some indication that the loving God about whom I preached was really there.  It never happened.  How could I not question his existence?  With the exception of one friend, everyone shushed me and told me not to let my mind entertain doubts. 

I did what they told me. I decided that no matter what, I would continue to believe. I continued to develop my career as a minister. I went back to school and got my Master of Divinity.  When I felt doubt I told myself what I told other people: “You still have a choice.”

I chose to believe until I gave up. 

You know what? I lost some friends, a career, and a marriage, but life didn’t end for me. It started to get better.  I started to grow rather than diminish.  A year later, I have a little more peace and feel a little less broken. I have love and happiness. I have new thoughts and new opportunities. 

So back to the question: What do I call myself?

That’s easy.  I am David

What Will Happen When I Die?

What happens to us after this life? I’m dying to know….

My consciousness… that presence behind the eyes that processes my thoughts and experiences–does it drift away and go somewhere else?   Does it turn off with a small blip like the screen of a computer? Is it like sleep where the consciousness relaxes and simply lets go so it can live in its dreams? Does it ever awaken again?

As I get older and the physical brain atrophies will there actually be less identity or will it still be there fully formed, gradually imprisoned a small increment at a time, subject to slower blood flow and fragile brain cells ? When the body comes to a full stop, will the mind be released to return to its complete version, or will it simply fire one last synapse before it’s gone?

What happens when a body comes to a sudden violent stop? Does the consciousness disappear instantly, or does it wander about like someone who lost everything when a tornado destroys her home in an instant?

When I see the body of a loved one at a funeral, I find myself watching for the chest to rise and fall, allowing myself a small hope that maybe it has all been a mistake and the person is still alive.  It’s nearly impossible to accept that a life simply ceases.  But there doesn’t seem to be proof one way or the other about an afterlife unless we accept the accounts of people who were technically unalive and then brought back.  Is there really a bright light for us to go toward where people wait to welcome us? What about those of us who are sure we’ve seen loved ones after their deaths? About half of those surveyed say they have experienced this. Do we discount those reports simply because we don’t understand how it could be true?

Is there another state of existence? Those interested in quantum physics have been discussing the idea of different dimensions existing within each other, but it’s becoming passé these days.   Others say that our individuality fades into a collective consciousness.  Perhaps that’s what Jesus was trying to say when he prayed, “May we all be one, Father… I in thee, and thee in me, and they in us.”

Or is it all just a physical and chemical thing, where the life impulse dies when the body succumbs to the law of entropy and becomes integrated with the rest of the earth, and the only reincarnation is when the atoms come together again in a reformation of life? I have to admit that’s kind of amazing.

All I know is that this life is passing quickly which sometimes fills me with an urgency to make everything count while I still exist. Other times, I remember to be less urgent and simply enjoy each moment. Often, I am filled with relief to know that one day I’ll be finished. I will have done my best but now I get to stop. And if it is a matter of simply blinking out of existence, that’s okay with me.

Hell: NO!

Tis the season for Halloween.  Many churches object to the holiday, calling it satanic, yet at the same time, some of those churches will offer alternatives that are truly satanic. Their haunted houses (often called, “Hell House”) offer images of hell complete with fire, demons, and torture. You know, fun for the whole family. 

Did you know the word for hell is not in the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) at all? It’s only mentioned once in the New Testament (2 Peter 2:4).  A few other verses speak of something we assume refers to hell but there’s a lot of room for discussion about it. 

Our concept of hell comes from Dante or perhaps Milton and we’ve added to it over the centuries.  We’ve certainly used it to frighten and control people, especially the children, and that troubles me greatly. Fear of hell was always a rotten motivator, however it can stoke the general anxiety of people.  

I always soft pedaled the eternal punishment part of my preaching even in my early period when I was a conservative fundamentalist.  A few years back I quit believing the church’s teaching on it because it just didn’t hold up theologically.  In my final years, I did not speak of it at all from the pulpit and I quietly told individuals that my thoughts had changed on the subject.

I observe that hell has lost a lot of its fire these days.  It doesn’t appear to scare us so much anymore, which suits me fine. 

Forget Heaven. I’m Living Now

I don’t want to take away something that is precious to another but I no longer believe there’s a heaven. 

I used to count heavily on the hope of a hereafter.  I preached about it often and referred to it in my funeral sermons. But as I said, I’m done with the concept.

For those who regard the Bible as indisputable… scripture doesn’t give substantial descriptions of heaven. Most of our images come from Revelation which is highly figurative and kind of useless in giving us a real concept. So our discussion of heaven is speculative. 

It’s supposed to be an incentive for people to aspire to goodness.  But we made it unattainable and so we had to figure out another way to get there—hence all the talk of the Only Begotten Son and the Great Sacrifice. In that context, motivation for doing good became a bit harder to explain.

For some, heaven is a great reward after an unhappy life. The idea provides comfort in times of grief and hardship.  But I’ve known many people who work hard to be unhappy.  They deny themselves joyful experiences because their religion smothers them with disapproval, harsh discipline and guilt.  No sex, no celebration, no parties, no dancing—if it’s joyful then it’s wrong.  Better to focus on hard work, grim worship, and self denial.  And be sure to make everyone else’s life miserable too (it’s their form of evangelism). The one hope they have is that things will be wonderful in the next life.   But will they be able to enjoy things then? No matter… they probably won’t make it anyway, even after all their efforts.

Many Christians use heaven as an excuse for not taking responsibility for the problems of this world. Since everything is going to be okay eventually, we don’t have to fix global warming, poverty, and human trafficking. It’ll all be made right in the sweet by and by. 

From now on, I’m going to assume that this life is what I have.  I need to take responsibility for it. I’m not going to close my eyes to the world’s problems.  I’m going to try and make things better if I can and I’ll cut myself some slack if I don’t find a grand solution. I just want to be part of the process.

I’m also going to enjoy my life more. I’m going to see new sights, walk on the seashore, hike in the mountains, take naps, go on adventures, eat good food, have music, binge on Netflix, and make love often. 

I’m going to make this life count. And if heaven turns out to exist after all… well, that’ll be great, too.

No More Church Buildings

Could I make a suggestion to churches? Get out of the property business.  

I mean it. Every small town I lived in has heavily mortgaged unused gyms and half filled sanctuaries and I’ve been seeing them since I became a minister in the 1980s. 

Let me say this as clearly as I can:

NEW BUILDINGS MAKE CHURCHES SMALLER.

And if your church is struggling, a new building could kill it. But even if it survives, all its other ministries are curtailed in order to pay off the debt.

I have walked through many empty buildings and felt my bile and blood pressure rise as my footsteps echoed across the floors of empty meeting rooms.  I would  pass through the kitchens and think of gossip sessions and turf battles waged as casseroles and fried chicken were prepared.  In the hallways, expensive stained glass images stared down at me while I glared up at them. 

Meanwhile, within sight of those buildings, people were going hungry. Neighborhood churches could have fed them for years with the money they had tied up in property.     

 “But we’re in the business of saving souls,” they protest.  And I say no they’re not.  Buildings do not tend to the souls of people. Do a little counting and see that while the property values go up, the number of people attending church goes down. 

“But the church down the street is doing well and they have a nice church building.”  Assuming it’s correct that the church is doing well, they didn’t become successful because of the building. They built the building to accommodate their success.   And I say they shouldn’t have built the building anyway.

Perhaps Christians could become more tolerant of different religious styles and learn to worship together in bigger groups. They could combine their resources to do actual work–Christ’s work, presumably.    

Jesus told the rich young man, “Sell everything you have, give the money to the poor, and follow me.” Perhaps in the spirit of that command, churches could sell off their properties and use the money to actually work for their God.

The focus should be on people not property.

I Thought I Would Be Angry

Most people who leave the church are quite angry. I am not although I thought I would be.

Oh, some people deliberately tried to harm me and I could get pretty angry at them.  In some cases, I held a grudge for years. However, my anger faded quickly once I got away.  It helps tremendously to be in happier circumstances and under less pressure. I mean, what do I have to angry about now?

Not all people are so fortunate. When they left their churches they lost their families, homes, friends, and jobs.

I think some people get angry because they felt like they’ve been brainwashed. The anger equips them to fight back the mind control they experienced over the years.  It takes a lot of energy to resist, especially if you have bullies in your life who use religion to manipulate and bully. However, I overcame a lot of that while I was still working within churches.

The truth is that while some people did evil within the church, most of them wanted to do good. When they failed, it was because of weakness and fear, not malevolence.  When I think of them, I remember their wounds more than my own, which are healing.   And I remember with gratitude the lovely gifts and the unbelievable kindness they gave to me.

I may have left a religious culture behind but my heart still cares for the people.

United Methodists Helping Victims of Harvey

One of the things that makes me proud to be a United Methodist is how they respond in times of disaster. Many United Methodist Church buildings are designed to be emergency centers and their doors will be open. 

They have a committee called UMCOR–United Methodist Committee On Relief that is active in helping people in times of crisis.  They were in the Houston area before the hurricane hit with supplies and emergency kits that were prepared earlier this summer by volunteers at Annual Conferences–they keep supplies stored for the next disaster.  A fund is set up that will give 100 percent of the money given directly to the effort (administrative costs are covered by other means).  Mission teams will be there throughout the ordeal and will continue to work there for years until the work is done.  

Mission teams are still helping rebuild places that were affected in past disasters.  

You can give your support to them through any local United Methodist Church or you can find them at http://www.umcor.org/.  

 

Why Aren’t We the Innovators?

Jesus replied, “Very truly I tell you, no one can see the kingdom of God unless they are born again.”

“How can someone be born when they are old?” Nicodemus asked. “Surely they cannot enter a second time into their mother’s womb to be born!”

“You are Israel’s teacher,” said Jesus, “and do you not understand these things?”

–John 3:3-4, 10 (NIV).

————————————————–

We followed mirages,

And fought over their reality.

I tried to help carry others

But now I don’t.

I stumble forward by myself…

—————————————————-

We brought in an enthusiastic speaker to get us revved up. He spoke our old beliefs as if they were brand new. He was funny, positive, and spoke in a rhythmic cadence that invited us to shout our hallelujahs and amens.

“Turn to your neighbor and say, ‘Jesus is ALIVE!’” And everyone did but me.

Later, a friend asked me “What did you think of it?”

“I think everything we said tonight was exactly the same as what we said in the 1970s, only we’re all grayer and slower.”

“Maybe we need to be reminded to go back to our old ways,” my friend suggested.

Maybe our old ways led to our decline,” I countered.

Jesus once said that we must be born again. He didn’t mean that we needed to return to infantile ways or to go back to do it all again the same way. I think he was saying to let go of the old ways and become something that we have never been before. We need to reach higher planes of awareness by thinking new thoughts and dreaming new dreams.

But we’re not doing that. We never have. The church has always expended most of its energy in staying exactly the same, keeping the same beliefs intact, and repeating the same activities. In fact, people will fight hard against newness and they hurt those who challenge the church effectively.

Why?

Why isn’t the church a champion for creativity, experimentation, and innovation? Why didn’t we celebrate Copernicus and Galileo? Why aren’t we more curious about scientific discovery? Why aren’t we leading the way in social change?

I don’t know. And to tell the truth, I’m losing interest in analyzing why we’ve failed. I’m only interested in moving forward, even if it’s by myself.

The apostle Paul once said that we were baptized to walk in newness of life. But we are scared to do it. It’s much easier to march toward death while insisting we are right.